City Council Meeting, 11/10/2026
0:01 one. Welcome all and I want to thank everybody for coming and I want to thank the wonderful people in our gallery for being here and I think we have a couple of informative sessions coming up.0:13 Okay, Mr. Dehaney.0:14 All right. So, Mr. Mayor, me members of council at this time, we'll be joined by deputy city manager Monica Kroski. She's going to give city council an overview of the mayor's task force for safe Virginia Beach and also go over the recommendations from the task force.0:29 Uh, thank you, Mr. Manager, Mr. Mayor, Madame Vice Mayor, members of council.0:35 Um, I would say there's certain work assignments that like refill your public administrator tank. Uh, this definitely has been one of those assignments that gets you excited about the work again.0:49 Um, being able to support this 19 person task force has really been special. um and now having the opportunity to share their work feels really privileged um and anchored in a good bit of responsibility to do it well. Um so for today, this is the road map for the presentation.1:14 Um want to give you upfront of what we're looking from you for you uh to do for us today. Uh revisit the mayor's charge. Uh talk about who answered the call for that charge. many of who are in the gallery today. Um talk about the process that they use um ultimately highlight the recommendations and um really talk about where to from here. Um you'll see or maybe you read in the paper uh what some of1:42 the recommendations are. It's a mixture of long-term and shortterm.1:48 um some that can be done administratively by executive leadership, some that require your um support, others that will require the general assembly. Uh so really want you to receive the recommendations today, perhaps interact with them, maybe keep an ear out. There are some that you might think fit nicely in your focus action plan. So be thinking of people, places, partnerships. Um, so with that,2:16 just a reminder of how we got here. Uh, in the spring, there were really three incidents of mass violence that really offended the sensibilities of the community. Um, we wanted better, the community want better for their neighbors, for our young adults, for businesses. Uh, so really it was a call to action. Um, the mayor responded by putting together a task force. Uh, this went well beyond public safety. and2:43 branched over into community safety. So knew we needed partnerships to come up with the right solution. Um the mayor wanted uh recommendations that were practical, that were sensible and rooted in the community's voice. Um 19 people answered the call uh for that charge, starting with the co-chairs bipartisanship uh for state delegation. I'm not sure.3:09 I'm sure Council Member Henley knows if this is a first or not. As the historian on the council, I'm not sure if we've ever had a local government task force headed by state delegation and a bipart.3:19 She's saying no. So, this is this was a milestone historic. Um, and then they were joined by 17 people uh very diverse people. A lot has been written about how how diverse. I think one article said a DJ, a pastor and a prosecutor walk into a conference room.3:39 Um very very diverse. I think sometimes the only thing that they had in common uh was how deeply they care about this community. Um, these were folks who had very strong opinions, um, intellectual independence and security, um, enough so to have their perspectives and views examined and scrutinized by each other, um, while at the same time remaining open uh, to encountering perspectives that perhaps4:07 they would not have arrived on um, at on their own. Um, we'll talk about more on that later. Um, so that's the task force, but they were supported by quite a lot of people. Um, we knew we were going to have diverse perspectives. I think Marisha in one of her reporting called it spirited uh discussion that we had at one of the community events. Uh, we knew that was going to be the case when the mayor4:31 assembled this groups and we wanted to have professional facilitation. Uh, so we had professional facilitation at each of the six-hour six-hour four-hour uh meetings that they had. Uh the MALS agency did the facilitation for the um community sessions that we had. Um Stand Up for Kids, Nicole CEO, she really helped us and you'll hear about that later in a few other slides, as well as4:57 a whole host of other internal folks who wanted to support the task force work to make sure that they were able uh to to give the best product possible. um several departments, uh the sheriff's office for allowing us in and interviewing some of the incarcerated young adults. Um OPA did research for us. Um legislative affairs showed up every single meeting. Dana came to every single meeting to make sure the5:24 attorney's office was represented. Um comps from videos.5:29 Um, I would be remiss if I didn't by name think Raven Emanuel, who is my executive assistant, who approached every single meeting um, with such care of wanting to make sure that the task force was uh, taken care of and who's always such a key ingredient to any and everything that I do. Um, so I know in typically it's proper to give thank yous and acknowledgements at the end. Uh but I5:54 think it's important to know how much talent, how much diversity went into um this work so that you can have a true appreciation um for the outcome.6:07 And at this point, if I think it's appropriate, would uh anybody on the committee please stand up and be recognized and let the people see you on TV.6:22 Thanks for creating that opportunity to do that, mayor. Uh so I want to highlight the path, the route, how they approached their work. Um three major areas, hearing from the community, following the data. Uh Delegate Fagens made sure that uh data was a grounding aspect for us and scanning the space because we knew that we weren't the first ones taking on this type of work.6:47 So hearing from the community is exactly what we did. Um we held three community sessions. We did a survey that got over 400 um participants. The Boys and Girls Club allowed us to uh give questionnaires to their young folks. Um and we also did targeted engagements.7:05 Um I'm not going to go through all that we heard from the task force. I would be here um for quite some time. But um many of you attended some of the sessions we had with business folks, community, faith leaders. Um, so being able to talk to folks and listen to some of the incarcerated young adults talk about the fact that uh they wish they had seen possibilities for their future earlier.7:32 Uh we heard them talk about it was hard for them to grapple what school meant for them when they were hungry but too embarrassed to tell their teachers they needed to make money. um when we went and we interviewed uh some of the young adults at Standup for Kids who were recently unhoused and you hear about transportation barriers. We heard about that in the community meetings. You hear7:55 about um whether or not folks felt welcomed at certain spaces, um how they couldn't access opportunities for various reasons. All of that fed into the task force's discussions and some of their recommendations.8:11 um following the data. Uh we had several presentations, what felt like several. I think the chief would have liked even more opportunities to share his data. Uh but making sure we were grounded in data and what we discovered, what we knew um is that Virginia Beach is a safe place.8:29 Uh we are one of the safest um of our size when we look at our peers and even when we look at ourselves over time we are living in one of the safest time the lowest crimes not just citywide but also at the oceanfront.8:46 So it's important to know that we're talking about getting safer. We're working from a place of strength um but wanting to understand how can we make our community better um and safer.8:58 Something else that came up through examining the data is realizing that people from the ages of 18 to 24 were insanely over represented and being both victims as well as suspects. So these folks are having experiences that impact the rest of their lives and potentially what they can be. Um so that really stuck with the task force um and became really a age group um that they wanted9:27 to make sure that we addressed in this effort scanning the space. I'm sure you all can read all of that text. Um but it was important that we gave respect to the work that already been done. Uh we know other folks have looked at what are ways to reduce violence and crime in communities. Um, so OPA did tons of research of looking at programs for violence interruptors, um, conflict resolution, and trying to9:57 look at programs that have been evaluated by other parties so that we could benefit from evidence-based strategies and practices. Um Hampton Roads Planning District Commission a couple of years ago did a regional roundt of uh with the mayors and the city managers and the police chief uh to pick their brains on what are the root causes of violence in our area. Um and it's interesting10:25 because when you look at the task force diverse 27 recommendations, a lot of this gets at some of the root causes. Um because for people to feel safe, uh the task force conversations really talked about folks need to feel safe socially, economically, and physically. It's not just about physical safety. It's about social safety. It's about financial safety. And when you look deep into the10:49 fishbone, the fishbone diagram that gets at risk root causes talks about that. Um so for some of folks when they look at the 27 recommendations that the task force talks uh has you might say that doesn't have to that's not physical it's not immediate but it's looking at it holistically.11:08 So that's a very highlevel overview of uh the route that they took. You can find the details of what the community said. You can read the research that OPA did and that the planning district gave at virginia.gov/safervb. back/safervb.11:27 But to getting back to the recommendations, um I I think it's participatory governance and group project at its best. Um going back to the earlier slide of showing just the diversity of lived experiences, perspectives and priorities that the 19 folks brought to the table to be able to arrive at 27 recommendations that people feel good about um really restores their my view and humanity. And um it was just11:57 really great to watch them talk about heavy topics, race and access um and be able to do in a way that was respectful of other people's perspectives and be able to co-produce and co-create these 27 recommendations.12:15 Uh they're divided into two parts. Uh resort area spring season as well as the community. Um, and again going back to that fishbone, it really gets to what does safety safety beyond just the physical sense. Um, so resort area, there's pretty much four areas. Um, we'll we'll dive deeper into these. I will not read recommendation by recommendation. Um, but I'll highlight the ones that are probably not as12:45 self-explanatory.12:47 Uh, the task force had lots of conversations about communications and branding. Um there was this sense that we spend a lot of effort and there's a lot of resources behind protecting our brand out of market uh tap resources and the great work that CBB does. But they had a lot of conversation of almost needing to promote our brand locally so that our neighbors can understand we're13:14 safe. We have tons of things going on.13:17 Um, and there's this sense that there's a disproportion disproportionate amount of negative uh publicity or media that we get and feeling as though the city should take um stronger lead in making sure that we share our message that we are incredibly safe. Um, recommendation B got a lot of creativity going amongst the task force. There's this idea of like I think it's when you go to airports or football games, they're13:46 nodding. Um there will be uh videos uh where folks are talking about the expectations and they felt like we could have one that could be talking about our community values and we could have some of our native sons and daughters not just government officials but they felt like it should be diverse folks whether it's some of our um many famous singers or athletes and just talk about in Virginia Beach we respect14:14 our surroundings in Virginia Beach we walk on sidewalks in a fun, quick way that expresses what our values are and our expectations are and do it in a format that could be used in different ways, whether it's hotels, whether it's show social media, um, but really tell our story of what we expect using um, a diverse people who live here and are from here.14:39 Uh, the second one is really talking about being a better steward of the footprint, the physical footprint of the resort area. Um, recommendation C got lots of uh, traction, and this really talks about closing um, sections of Atlantic Avenue during the spring season on Fridays and Saturdays and having it programmed uh, with our beach events partners and making it into more of a pedestrian mall. Um and then similar to15:06 airports, if you go to a football professional football game or a concert, they typically have zones of where we have um what do you call these people now? Ride sharing, Ubers and lifts. Um so feeling as though it might be smart to have certain zones. Again, just trying to keep a better um control and management of the footprint and then establishing hours for the parks and open spaces that we have down there.15:35 Uh this other section talks about enhancing the physical appearance of our resort area. Lots of discussion when folks would have ideas. Uh there would be someone who would say that's in the um Atlantic Avenue project. That's in the Atlantic Avenue project. So, lots of momentum behind wanting the city to proceed with the recommendations from the AT Atlantic Avenue improvements project. Um, property standards and how16:00 it looks at the oceanfront came up quite a bit. Um, and feeling as though we needed to have stronger um, control or more consistent enforcement of the rules for code enforcement. Um, for some on the task force, it felt to them that certain business types u whether it be hotels uh feeling as though um enforcement is heavier on them than maybe certain other types of businesses.16:31 Um and they we also talked about uh the delegate gave an example of Portsmith of how they will have multi- not the delegate the senator gave uh an example of Portsmith of how they have multid-disciplinary teams. There will be someone from the health department coming with someone from uh building codes and the fire inspection and they will go to the businesses all at once to make it more efficient. Um so felt like16:58 that needed to be done but they wanted it to be done in a way that was pragmatic um not in a way that um got it in the way of people being able to do business. And they felt like H went along quite well with G. Um I understand that the facade grant program, one of the recent improvements was lowering um the match that's needed and they felt like we needed to promote that more and17:22 maybe do cross promotion promotions as we're going in there and doing these inspections. Let folks know that hey remember we have this facade grant program and we also lowered the matching requirement.17:37 Uh strengthening public safety through partnerships. heavy emphasis on partnerships. The task force was not interested in trying to replace the police department. They felt like there was opportunity to do partnerships. Uh so the violence interrupters program feeling as though let's do something at the ocean front recognizing that would be trailblazing. Typically um violence interruption programs are done in18:03 neighborhoods and communities. Um but there is a feeling of let's try it. Um some of the caveats that we learned through research, some of these programs, they're not equally organized, right? There are some programs that are um heavy in reporting requiring whoever they rep um whoever they partner with, they give uh reports of what activities have you done? Um how have you engaged18:27 the community? So the task force thought it would be important uh to incorporate some of those reporting requirements. I want to say it's Baltimore that had the program. Um, yes, that the task force really liked. Chuck and Melissa are not in their heads. Um, so that's something we'll want to dig in more to maybe replicate some of those elements. Um, Jay, collaborate with aspiring event18:53 organizers to develop more structured unstructured events while also providing a pathway for entrepreneurial development. I feel like this is another one that got their creative juices flowing. It even got the Zurle nod of approval. Um, and that's saying a lot.19:11 That's a lot. Zero lottery ticket.19:16 Uh, so this one is recognizing there's two ways or several routes that the committee um is recommending. one is like doing this incubator cohort um of events and entertainment where folks could learn about the special events process. um they could learn from um established businesses and then one of their capstone projects could be programming a city space. Doesn't necessarily have to be at the oceanfront19:47 but a city space um for a particular day or hours um so that they get the opportunity to put what they learn into practice. Um, another thought was to have um these aspiring event organizers pitch ideas for particular spaces of what they would do. Um, and these are designed or the idea is that these would be um smallcale in nature whether it's a dance contest um or not. There was a quote that Gabe20:17 said, Gabe is our creative DJ producer on the task force and he said a quote in one of the meetings that stuck with um with Raven and she typed it up for me.20:29 Uh Gabe, it's when you said inclusion fosters self-governance. When people are given ownership, they feel involved and govern themselves and others. So the sense that if we allow them to be part of um an event, they're going to want people to behave appropriately. Um so to make sure that is a success. Um so Jay is really interesting an opportunity um to create a third space for folks while20:56 giving them an opportunity to program it and to develop um their entrepreneurial um aspect. K. Um, folks really want to make sure that bars aren't oversharing, uh, over sererving. Uh, I know the chief in one meeting talked about he would love it even though he understands that ABC they have their own staffing woes, but he would love it if he can get an ABC agent embedded in our police force.21:24 Um, so I think that's on his wish list.21:28 So that's for the spring season uh resort area. Broader community, you'll see way more categories because again that's getting to people feeling safe socially, financially, and not just physically.21:43 So legislation and policy um really following up on this community safety zone. I know Brent and Jesse will be talking to you all about that next.21:54 Sim essentially the task force is interested in supporting that u maintaining the curfew that's the 1000 p.m. to 5 p the 5 a.m.22:04 um for 18 and and under. Um drones came up quite a bit. Um interested. Currently there's quite a bit of restrictions on when drones can be used. Um essentially the chief has to wait until an incident happens. Um, and there was discussion on the task force about getting it narrowly tailored so that it's for these larger communities like us that have a lot of crowd management control because if I'm22:34 not messing it up, Dana, we can pull out our helicopter at any point without having to wait. So, um, being able to use the most more coste effective drone um, to be able to do the crowd management is desirable. Um, so there's interest in that being a legislative ask.22:56 Uh, lots on mental health. Um, these are all connected. Um, O really talks gets to the heart of it and we know it's a stretch for this session. Uh, the delegate in the senator talked about it too, but wanting to get it on the radar.23:12 Um, talked about there's uh, peers in other states that maybe have a more streamlined approach. Um, as you can see those stats, uh, mental health calls account for about 2% of the police department's 911 calls, but about 11% of their, um, directed patrol time. So, really ties up quite a bit resources and even more than tying up the resources.23:38 There's [clears throat] a desire to make sure that our neighbors who are in mental health crisis have access to the professionals who are best positioned to help them. and law enforcement. They care about the community, but that's not necessarily what they're trained for. So, looking for the opportunity to have a pilot that would allow for more of a streamline integrated mental health approach. Um,24:02 special conservators of peace of the peace um gets to trying to reduce the amount of time that uniform law enforcement are um in taking folks who are in custody.24:17 Um the chief gave examples of sometimes they have to wait or drive six hours away to find a bed, sit with them, drive six hours and that takes um folks from off the patrol street and as you all know we have our own vacancies and making sure that the chief is able to maximize the resources is important. So these are folks who can be sworn in.24:39 Most of them are retired officers. Um, and they would be able to help with the transportation of the temporary detention orders and emergency custody orders. So, this is one that's already in progress. Uh, chief needs to I won't say pick up the pace. He's not here. Uh, so I can give him a hard time. Uh, this is the task force nudging him that he needs to move forward um in earnest uh25:02 with getting this program off the ground. Um, similar with Q, we have um two types of mental health teams. One that's co-responds with the police department, a separate one from human services that's nonp police interventions. And the task force is just interested in both kinds uh both of those teams receiving additional funding.25:28 Communications and marketing. Um, R is one where lots of discussion this evolved. Um, and it really came to wanting to use the communication channels to talk about gun safety storage. Uh, I know the police department recently got a grant for gun storage devices. I think the sheriff's office has certain initiatives and just wanting to make sure that we're using our channels to promote that at the25:54 state level. the senator and delegate was saying how they recently passed some tax incentives um related to gun storage. So, wanting to make sure that we're helping to get the word out. Um there was lots of talk of feeling as though we have various apps and websites about what's going on.26:13 There's um the task force had a lot of discussion about we have events, we have programs, but how do we get that in the hands of the people who need it? Um, so there's this thought that between the various VB connects, BBGO, Ages and Stages, which they love, Tiffany Connie got a presentation at an event he was at and was blown away by ages and stages.26:36 Um, but there's a feeling that there's an opportunity to streamline it.26:41 And if we can't streamline it, is there a way that we can crossromote? So if you're on one site, it'll take you to another site. Just feeling like streamline communication can actually help get the word out better. Um and then the use of social media influencers, understanding that we do it for CVB. U Michael Kershman also briefed the um task force and talked about he how he used it. Um but wanting to lean27:05 in that space more and making sure we have it with a lens of trying to connect with our younger folks. Um so getting in that new age of how people are consuming information and how people are influenced and then investing in youth and young adult opportunities.27:25 Um when we talked to the community, when uh the task force did their targeted interviews, just lots of feedback of access to opportunities lacking, but the importance of those opportunities of people being able to see potential for their future and needing to see that sooner. Um and that's what all of this UV and W is related to. So, apprenticeships. Um, I think one of the young men that was27:56 interviewed in jail talked about how he needed money and when you're too young to work, a lot of times the way that you make money could be illegal. Um, so making sure that we have apprenticeships that gives them not only skill sets and something to do for someone who's not interested in geometry or algebra, but also takes into effect into account the economic realities for some of our28:20 students. um increasing their access by making sure that they can have transportation. We heard so many um discussions about transportation. I know council member Rouse and Council Member Beluchcci, you two came to the community one and I think that's where we also heard quite a bit of uh discussion about folks being able to get to jobs um and get to opportunities. So idea around ride shared vouchers. Um, we had a28:49 school representative on the task force and there was discussion about we have this these fleet of buses. Is there a more creative way that we could use buses beyond just the traditional taking people to school and and um back home?29:02 So, the sense that the city should take a lead role um in the apprenticeships and the transportations um and then encouraging partners to join us. Um, and then [clears throat] W is really just looking at uh digital programs or apps and how we can do peer-to-peer connections. Uh, one of the folks that was unhoused talked about were recently unhoused at Stand Up for Kids talked about how when they left the29:31 structure of high school and they didn't go straight to college, how it felt very isolating. Um, how they felt like they lost the network because they were no longer involved in structured recreational. they didn't have the class. So, looking at how can we address this social capital almost of um folks feeling socially connected and these last couple of categories, environmental design, street lighting,30:02 um for the resort area, conversation about smart lighting. I didn't even know such thing exist. But having the ability to if there is an incident or if there's an area where police uh needs to literally shine a brighter light on, there's smart lights of where they can create uh increase the illumination. Um so wanting to pursue that for uh the resort area. And then out in the community, uh the delegate particularly30:29 talked about how a lot of folks don't know how to report street lights being out. So wanting almost like a communications campaign of letting people know who they should call, what information they should gather um to report outages to make sure that um we have proper street lighting throughout our community.30:48 then why really gets to this under thread of access and transportation and the task force wasn't necessarily convinced that traditional buses was the most cost-effective or the most um prudent way to enhance transportation um and really wanted to see the city develop a microtransit strategy uh and being an employer of choice for police officers making sure that we have a competitive SL salary in the region31:15 for our police officers And the final recommendation uh talks about community partnerships, recognizing the city doesn't have to be the one to always do things and how we have so many programs and opportunities in the community, but how we need to do a better job of connecting folks. Um so this was uh resources757.org is an area where the task force thought maybe the city could partner, get31:42 involved in this. Um you probably can't see the lettering, but these icons. So if you are interested in housing assistance, mental health, it's a website that serves as a hub that can connect you to resources. So the idea that the city could partner with, I think this is done by um not stand up for kids, there's an organization that runs this, a nonprofit that runs this site um and if they had32:09 the support and the backing of the city, what could this potentially um be? I know that that was one of the mayor's um goals for hope is how do we connect people to the resources that they need?32:21 So potentially partnering uh with this organization.32:26 So where to next? Um as I said at the top of this administratively there's some of these that we can move forward with. Um, if there are some that really resonate with council and you want it folded into your focus, action plan of people places partnerships can definitely do that. There are some in the general assembly that we'll need their concurrence on. Um, but the task force ask is that this not lay on a32:52 shelf collecting dust. Um, their ask is that we operationalize these uh recommendations.33:00 Um, so before I close, there's two very important people who wanted to be here, but because they've already started heading to Richmond and serving us, they couldn't be here. Um, and their schedules are so hectic. Um, but they really wanted to record a message and it was important for them to do it together. they didn't want to come here and do it separately because the way that they co-chared the33:27 the task force even though they might sit on different sides of the owl. Uh they led the court uh the task force side by side. Uh so they wrote their own script and they came in on Friday and they have a couple of words that they want to say to the task force to council and the community.33:44 Hello, this is Delegate Michael Fagens and I want to thank my great fellow co-chair, Senator Christy New Craig and every member of the Virginia Beach Safety Task Force for their hard work and dedication. Over the past several months, we've listened to our community and developed datadriven recommendations focused on strengthening public safety all across Virginia Beach. I'm proud of what we've34:05 accomplished together and hope city council will build on this work by implementing recommendations that can be carried out locally. Our goal, it's always been simple. Build and highlight what's working, address areas where we can improve, and continue moving our entire city forward.34:22 Hello, this is Senator Christina Craig.34:25 It was an honor to serve as co-chair of the Virginia Beach Safety Task Force. Throughout this process, we remain committed to advancing practical community focused recommendations that enhance public safety while strengthening trust among residents, businesses, schools, and public safety agencies. The task force carefully examined emerging challenges, evaluated best practices, and encouraged34:46 meaningful dialogue among a diverse group of stakeholders. This collaborative approach allowed us to develop thoughtful recommendations designed to support a safer, stronger, and more resilient Virginia Beach. I am grateful for the dedication and contributions of my fellow task force members, city staff, law enforcement partners, school representatives, business leaders, and community participants. Their expertise,35:09 commitment, and willingness to engage in constructive discussion were instrumental in shaping outcomes that reflect the needs and priorities of our community. Together, we have laid groundwork for continued progress in promoting safety, accountability, and quality of life for all who live, work, and visit Virginia Beach.35:27 Look at that. One tank Jake over here.35:31 I had a ball shooting that.35:34 So, with that, Mr. Mayor, happy to take any questions. Okay, let's set open up for comments.35:39 Jennifer, fantastic.35:41 I'm so happy about this and to and to keep it alive and keep it at the forefront. My brain is spinning. So, there's a lot of like going all these different places and really the framework it's it it really is as simple as when and there's all sorts of theories of crime and deviant. So, it's not original, but when people are integrated into their communities, when they're bonded, they have things to do,36:04 uh, things to lose where if I get in trouble, there's something that I can lose and I don't want to risk that. They have healthy attachments to people that, uh, that show them the way, but also that they want to make proud and they don't want to disappoint, that they have a belief system and a value system, that they're involved in things that they're too busy to get in trouble. There's all36:22 of all of this is here. And I think that as we look forward to our uh focused action plan and we think about our priorities going forward, if we keep the youth in mind, everything else is gonna improve. [clears throat] If if cuz if youth are good, that means their adults are good, their parents are good, whoever is taking care of them.36:38 And what do they need to be good? Stable housing, stable jobs, stable income, everything is affordable. So if we keep them in mind, the youth in mind that their lives are stable, ultimately the community is going to be stable. So absolutely I think when we go into the retreat um in January I'd love this to be at the top of mind as we consider our priorities and um uh not only for staff37:01 [clears throat] but for our resources too sociologist I can go back you when you you and I joined you when you hosted uh you know the youth at the boys and girls club and there was one thing about the uh the curfew for the teenagers and what you remember their I thought it was a surprising comment.37:23 They were like, "Yeah, it's fine."37:24 They were like, "Yeah." You know, but I think some of them they're already in the Boys and Girls Club, so it's like a kind of self- selecting group of folks.37:31 [clears throat] But in their mind, they were like, you know, we don't want we want to go to places and it not, you know, whether it's a takeover or whatever. We want to go somewhere and enjoy it and not kind of be on edge that something is going to happen like we so we don't mind the structure when it enables us to have a good time. I will say one more comment. When I was in37:49 Richmond, I've mentioned this before at the table, but it sounds familiar. Um, in Virginia Beach, we do [clears throat] have so many resources. So, it's not for lack of effort that we don't the it's the connection whether or not the resources are meeting the need as designed. So, that those are some questions that I have. Um, we might have the best intentions with what we're offering, but it may not be hitting the38:10 mark with what the public or these families actually need. So, figuring out what the gap it could be transportation or it could be. It's nice that you offer this, but actually my need is something else and we might need to tailor some of those things.38:24 Great. Anybody else?38:27 Okay, Amelia.38:28 Well, I like what you mentioned and thank you so much for this report. I like where you mentioned about the focus for people places that that could go in there because that picks up pretty much a lot of what you said.38:44 Thank you all and thank all the people who worked on this because this is important and we thank the mayor for initiating having this come up.38:53 Good job.38:54 Thank you.38:55 And then worth.38:57 Thank you. I just want to thank you all and thank you for making time to be here today.39:03 These are very serious issues. They're issues that have been faced by this community for decades. I grew up in Virginia Beach and I remember conversations about this tension at the resort and across the city as a child, as a little child. Um, and we're still facing them today. I think we have a unique opportunity in this generation to actually turn a corner and make a meaningful change in violence prevention39:30 in Virginia Beach. And I think this is a great next step in that process. I really do. Um, I like I mean there there's a lot of material here. This is very very meaty and meaningful material.39:42 Um, and it's going to require a tremendous amount of work in order to operationalize just even some [clears throat] of these, let alone all of them. There's nothing that stands out to me as being a problem. I these are all really fantastic and common sense um, recommendations.40:02 One of them that I want to focus on, there's a lot I could say. I'm like council member Rouse. my head is I don't know if I'd say spinning, but there's a lot jumping around up there. Um, but one thing that I've been excited to talk about, but I wanted to be respectful of the work and so I'm so happy to see this included in the work is the implementation of a violence interruption program. And I'm40:24 particularly want to call out that topic and wonder if you have any other additional thoughts about it or what the next steps could be. And I'll tell you why. Um, a lot of people have reached out to me about these programs, including people that want to participate in it, people that have opinions about it. [snorts] Uh people who think we should be adopting these programs as part of um not only at40:49 the oceanfront, but potentially in other parts of the city as well, but definitely at the oceanfront in the springtime.40:56 We don't have a lot of time, right? I mean, we're talking about months before we reenter this cycle. And so that's one question I have in in regard to the violence interruption program, but even more broadly into to borrow your phrase operationalizing the recommendations.41:15 What's our next step for doing that? And what would that look like in terms of a viol and let me be more specific about the the programs?41:25 It's going to not be cheap, but neither is the cost of the headlines.41:31 Neither is the um impact to businesses um and and most importantly the loss of life or harm to human beings that occurs and the perpetuation of the disconnection that's been a part of this. So I don't think we can afford not to try a violence interruption program.41:57 Patrick, Mr. Mayor Council Baluchcci, several of you all and members of our task force have been talking about a violence interrupt this program. The chief and I are exploring it. Um I think we're getting ready to actually even have a a mini procurement process go out to the various firms that have reached out for them to submit a proposal for us to consider. I think we're to the point42:21 now where we feel like it is something that we should try. It's probably something that we want to pilot for the ocean front, probably for the spring.42:30 Don't have a lot of details yet, but we are exploring it to the point of putting a scope out to get a sense of what it will cost and what it will look like.42:38 And it will probably come back to you all with more information about it. But we feel like we're to the point now where [clears throat and cough] we need additional support from somebody that is not the police helping us to have good authentic conversation with the young adults that come down [clears throat] and visit during the spring to help deescalate situations when they arise.42:56 Right. Majority of times when the kids come and the young adults come, we don't have an issue, but there are some situations that get contentious. That's probably better for a violence interrupter that's not necessarily wearing a police uniform to help to help deescalate conversations. So, we are looking at that and we do hope to be able to get something set up subject to council's um concurrence for the spring43:19 of this year. And let [snorts] me just follow up by that with this other point and SL question.43:26 As I mentioned before, we're not far we're four or five months away from this season again. Um I don't a lot of these things are going to take especially the general assembly activity and things you know they're going to have to be signed into law we're talking about now 28 for those action items.43:48 I don't I'm not asking you for an answer to this question today explicitly but we've got to have a plan for spring of 27 that's more robust than the plan we had last year. I think we all agree about that and there's a lot of information that can be pulled out of this that can be operationalized into the spring of 27. I know you're all thinking about this and you know but I44:10 would like I think as a next step we should have sort of a checklist of action items that will be implemented for this spring or at least that maybe you all recommend that we implement and if it requires any support on our part but we got to be I think very specific about what is our plan for spring of 27.44:28 Yeah. So, listen. Most of a good portion of the stuff on that list, like the stuff with the lights and um creating a pedestrian mall environment for Atlantic Avenue staff is already been working on as well. We're also working on with public works and um RMO like a spring cleaning initiative to get us ready for this um the tourism season as well.44:48 We'll be ready to bring something to you all probably if not December time frame, probably January about what our plan is for. some of the things we've already briefed you on about like working to get um park hours established for the oceanfront parks and the glide parks as well, you know. So, some of those things we already been kicking around, we'll be able to put it together in a45:06 comprehensive package, especially with the messaging that was discussed as well on how we plan to enter into the tourism season to kind of welcome folks, but also to set the expectations to keep our community safe, including oceanfront.45:21 Works in care.45:22 Thank you, Mayor. Thank you, Miss Croski. And again, thanks to the task force for a lot of work and the two co-chairs and there is a lot of meat here in my head spending as well and from A to Z to double A that's 27 recommendations. I just want to highlight a few that we just talked about and then just to highlight again or discuss how we're going to implement45:43 you know a lot of these because it's here in writing but the key is going to be in implementation. you just spoke to that, but yeah, closing down Atlantic Avenue during the spring and having some pedestrian uh participation in events there and entertainment. That's a I think that's a fantastic idea that we and it sounds like staff is already looking in to that. [snorts] Um you talked about branding and you talked46:06 about marketing within the city limits.46:09 I think that is really important that we all and I'll speak to this later in council comments about the value of tourism and how it really is to the betterment of our community that we are a very good tourist area. So we need to improve upon that and that speaks to that. Um and then of course you just talked about the general assembly and other things but um I just want to46:31 compliment you on that and how I think it's important that you're saying staff is already working on some of these. Do we have any votes or anything we need to do or adopt this?46:42 Not 100% certain yet. Obviously, some of these things are going to require financial um support beyond what staff can give. So, likely some of it may come as part of the budget. Um, and then some of these things may need policy enactment as well. So, I need a little bit more time to review it. But the things that we're working on to get us ready for the resort season in the47:04 spring, primarily most of them could be done within the administrative curfew.47:08 [clears throat] Obviously, we'll let city council know know where we're headed and some of those things may need additional appropriation. The pilot program for the um the violence interrupterss depending on the cost may be able to be absorbed within the existing budget. We'll communicate as we get that scope back and the proposals back from the vendors where we're going to go with that and47:28 we'll let you all know. But big picture, some of these things, as um Monica mentioned, are things that could be implemented fairly quickly. Most of those probably can be done within the staff purview. Some of them may need policy approval by city council or the general assembly as well. And we'll work to create a checklist as Mr. Beluchcci says of kind of what items or discuss what we can do internally and what we47:51 would need city council support or general assembly support to help you all in your policy decisions. And if I can remind folks that, you know, we did the pilot program [clears throat] after dark and it really turned out to be quite the investment. And so I think that was kind of cool. Okay, Cash and Josh, you're here. I'm I'm in agreement with the uh pilot program. I just want to48:12 thank the again the mayor's task force uh for a safer Virginia Beach. Uh that's very important. Thank you for your time, your commitment. [clears throat] And then the external programs that were a part of it, the contributors, the Berkeley Group, the Miles Agency, Stand Up for Kids, Boys and Girls Club, Hampton Roads Planning District Commission. I mean, that's to me the heart of how we deal with48:41 Virginia Beach being a safer city. It's the external organizations that we have, not just relying on the Virginia Beach Police Department, but our strength is in our organizations that we have. That's what makes us a safe city is we have people who volunteer their time, energy, and their talent. So, I'm grateful for you.49:06 So, I just want to say thank you and whatever we need to do to start the conversation for the pilot program. I'm in favor of that.49:16 Hey, Josh.49:18 Um, thank you, Mayor. Uh, [clears throat] Monica, thank you and to everybody who participated in the in the [snorts] process. Uh, our appreciation.49:26 Good to see you. Uh what interests me u certainly and I agree that there are things that we can work on implementing sooner rather than later but um but there's also some long-term um things and what caught my eye was this concept of uh the crime prevention through environmental design and especially as we we go about Atlantic Avenue and reinvesting as we continue to create spaces like uh VB Trail and Rudy Park49:54 for our community to [clears throat] enjoy. way. There's there's things through uh crime prevention, through environmental design like landscaping and low wall barriers and natural access points and crowd control kind of measures that kind of fade into the background that that help you when you have larger scale in uh events. um love the idea of um actively supporting youth programs in our public spaces,50:20 especially programs where they take ownership and it's their ideas and the um all of that work um would be really really great to see. Um and the special conservators of the piece that's already something that's authorized under state law. We we just have to go about doing it. Is that right?50:40 Yes. In city council, if you recall in last year's budget, you provided a police chief authorization to convert some positions to hire special conservative of the peace. I think he's in the process of defining the scope and getting ready to go out to start hiring some folks to help take that um burden off the police department in terms of supporting those that are experiencing um a mental health crisis.51:02 Well, if there's anything we have to do to formally accept this report, I would certainly [clears throat] be interested in doing that.51:09 Thank you. Again, I just want to add my thanks for the hard work that was done by the uh task force. It it certainly shows that it was very thoughtful, very deliberate.51:23 Uh, a number of these recommendations that we see here are inwardlooking and I think we would be remiss if we don't bring up the fact that the majority of the victims and the perpetrators of these crimes that grab the headlines are from people that are not from this area, not from Virginia Beach, not even necessarily from Hampton Roads.51:50 So, these are external people that are coming into our community. While I fully support our inward look and our uh mobilizing our our resources to do that, you know, I think that some of the the recommendations, especially maybe like the the violence interruptors we're talking about, can be [clears throat] uh can be used in a way to um focus on some of these external forces that come into our city52:21 to cause these these uh situations.52:27 Okay. Uh, let me just say before I'm sorry, Rose, [clears throat and cough] I just want to like everybody thank everyone for all this hard work and [snorts] the massive amount of work and suggestions that I think are going to really make a big difference. But and also to thank the co-chairs, but we really need to thank our mayor who came up with the idea for doing this and putting together such a diverse group that52:54 in a lot of situations would not have been able to come up with a cohesive that they could all agree on. So, you deserve a lot of credit for [clears throat] doing this. So, thank you.53:04 No, but I tell you what, no mayor does anything by him or herself. It's your people. It's about relationships. You know, it's about having trust in the community that they were going to come together. And I, you know, I thank you for that. But u let me just say you know I made a promise at the first meeting that we had that this was not going to be a report that sits on a shelf and53:28 gathers dust. This is a proactive uh playbook on how to achieve something that we have been chasing in this city for decades. You know if there were easy answers it would have been done decades ago. But the fact is that we had you [snorts] know when they started a big clump of clay and so many hands came on it and what you manufactured in this report is beautiful. It is a piece of is53:58 a piece of art. These are a lot of individual things people have been talking about for a long time but it was put into a context that actually formulated an action plan.54:12 And you we have uh two things. We have a retreat coming up. But the other thing is too, we have to, you know, and I am very grateful uh to the delegate and the senator, you know, from both parties that came together in a very bipartisan way with with the sole objective of, you know, taking care of the community. And that's the template that we need. And I I really think that, you know, once54:36 again, uh this is not only a template for the city of Virginia Beach. this could be the template, you know, for uh you know, the entire Commonwealth of Virginia going forward. And so I would recommend that we get together with our delegation, you know, to talk about the needs and, you know, to once again put the partisanship aside and say, okay, what do we need to do? Uh that could be54:59 really applicable to everybody in the Commonwealth. So I I I just want to, you know, say thank you to everybody, all concerned. Uh but once again know and uh staff uh yeah I tell you a lot of hours a lot of dedication and I think we came up with the winner. Thank you all and God bless you. Thank you.55:25 Okay. Uh now we're on to uh the draft legislative agenda.55:31 Well, here we are.55:34 Here we are at last. Um What I thought we would do is kind of get it prepared for next week's vote and things that don't have this board of eight members of council the regular legislative agenda and of course nine for the um [clears throat] charter change. We can call out the ones that don't then hopefully next week for our vote it'll be easier. And I also want to say just because you say you're56:02 okay with it today. If you change your mind by next week, that's okay. It can be pulled out. But I think maybe this will make it more.56:11 And so what I wanted to do is, and thank you uh Jesse very much for we we've got everything is kind of numbered and I think it's just easy to kind of go down and if you've got a question, Jesse's here to answer them. Um the first section is policy priorities and these are general things that we normally uh support. Uh one is affordable housing, economic development, education, energy, fiscal responsibility56:43 and budget impacts and environment, land use, public safety and transportation.56:51 Is there anything in that list?56:55 Well, these are kind of the general things that any that y'all have a problem with.57:00 And Mr. Mayor, Brent and Jess can give you just a quick overview of those. But as as the vice may mention, these are ones that we typically have and we articulate to um that either they allow localities to advocate for themselves and not even put rules upon us. They're generally just policy positions that we can advocate on things that come up along the way, right? So, is there any issues with any of these?57:28 Okay. Um All right. So, the first thing to to talk about is the budget amendment to expand the sales tax. This is number 10. Expand the [clears throat] sales tax referendum to authorize the authority for resiliency projects.57:46 If you have a problem with this, let us know. And I think it's easier to get the nos out there than the yeses.57:52 Stacy, I'm pretty much a hard no on this one.57:56 And my reasons are one, we had a referendum on how to deal with storm water. the storm water said storm water referendums uh authorized the council to uh increase the real estate tax to pay for the storm water. You council at that point in time decided not to do it and uh whether it was a good decision or a bad decision I'm not in a position to say. Wasn't on council but the people have already58:27 spoken about how they wanted the storm water uh to be dealt with.58:33 two, I think in this environment uh any any proposal to raise taxes um for for any reason is problematic.58:47 And I think that we saw in uh an overwhelming repudiation of this this whole concept across the across the state in this past election. And three, I think that um adding this brings uh questions to um constituents as to why are we doing this? And is, you know, is this a um is is this a underhanded way of trying to gain favorable support for uh an issue that we should be dealing with uh59:32 otherwise. So I I just think that um I don't think there's any appetite for it. I think that we've committed to addressing the storm water with the resources that we have and [clears throat] I don't I can't imagine our citizens passing a referendum whether it was just for the schools or or passing a sales tax increase whether it was just for the schools or splitting it out between the1:00:04 schools and storm water. I I I just I'd like to put our emphasis elsewhere.1:00:13 Okay.1:00:13 I'm also a hard no.1:00:16 I'm a no.1:00:17 I'm a know.1:00:18 Yeah. Okay.1:00:18 I'm a no.1:00:19 Okay. I think the nose have it.1:00:22 So that will not be in next week.1:00:23 It's not the right time. Affordability is [clears throat] Okay. Under the code amendments number 11, deferred retirement uh option for option plan for the public safety employees. Is anyone a no on this one?1:00:46 That one stays.1:00:47 That one stays. Number 12, the tourism development franchising program. Anybody know on that?1:00:57 Consensus is wonderful.1:00:59 Number 13 is community safety zone.1:01:06 Okay.1:01:08 Almost stays. Number 14, possession of firearms while intoxicated.1:01:15 Okay. Number 15, increase the representation of law enforcement on the U forensics science board.1:01:27 Okay, we're moving right along. Um, number 16, extend the court ordered uh time frame for temporary adult protective services.1:01:48 Uh number 17, update authority related uh for animal cruelty legisl uh registries.1:02:01 Number 18, increase certain traffic offenses from a secondary offense to a primary offense.1:02:09 I'm a no.1:02:10 Yeah. What is that one about? I want to Jesse, you want to explain that?1:02:15 Well, uh good afternoon. Uh, Mr. Mayor, Madam Vice Mayor, members of council, Councilman Hutchinson. Um, so this one is, you may remember in 2021 there was a series of traffic offenses that were reduced from a primary offense to a secondary offense. And I've got the list here and I'll pull it up here for one second once I stop talking. Um, this proposal would move um those back to a1:02:40 primary offense. And so it's things like a expired registration, a broken tail light um oops, I miss it. Oh, yeah, that's right.1:02:52 It was in the beginning.1:02:55 Here we go. Uh, so, uh, broken tail lights, excessive tinted windows, expired registration, not wearing a seat belt, objects hanging from the rearview mirror, marijuana order, odor, and jaywalking. These are what's commonly referred to as pretextual stops.1:03:11 Yeah.1:03:12 And so, so let me understand. So, you're saying they would move back into what you could be pulled for. Is that what we're talking about?1:03:19 So, currently they are a secondary offense, meaning they have to have uh um had some other offense occurring or some sort of um other speculation to be pulled over and then you could be ticketed for these items. Um, the mayor's proposal would be to move this to back to a primary offense where you could be pulled over just for any one of these items.1:03:45 Josh and Stacy.1:03:47 Um, so, so I know we've talked around the table about how difficult it is to be a police officer or a teacher, um, these days for that matter. um and that that there there were obviously these these uh primary offenses taken away like you know no longer tools in the belt so to speak and and I think we've also got to be really careful about um the the the demographics and the why1:04:15 behind why those were taken out and why they're why they're pretextual. And I think um [snorts] you know I don't if this came from PD and if this was chief asking us um I would want to kind of have an idea of what what putting any of those back in would would get us and what do what do what do those primary stops look like down the road? Do they lead to you know1:04:42 putting the worst people on the planet in jail? And do do the de do do the demographics of that subset of the population cause us any concern and rightfully so especially given the challenges of policing and community policing and that kind of whole discussion. So I mean I I don't think I mean me personally walking by a car that smells like marijuana I think everybody should agree that's pretty offensive and1:05:07 you know um bad for somebody driving or passengers or whatever. But um you know there's a lot of things that smell like mariju marijuana these days that aren't marijuana as well. So um and um but jaywalking um coming from a a council district that doesn't have a lot of crosswalks and sidewalks um I don't know I don't know how I don't know how to explain or rationalize that one in my1:05:31 head. I think and I also think if we go ahead and ask for this given the composition of the general assembly the likely answer is no. And I think it puts our more important ass at risk, especially the stuff we were just talking about with the ocean front and safety and stuff. So, I'm a no on this for those.1:05:51 Okay, Stacy.1:05:53 My question was just, is this all or nothing? I mean, we could whittle down if we wanted to.1:06:00 So, yes, sir, Councilman, uh, that's at your discretion.1:06:05 I tell you what, let me do this. Um, you know, let me put it this way. I think unity is very important at this table.1:06:14 And, you know, one of the things, you know, one of my intention is that people have to know, you know, we got to get back to being a commonwealth and a country of law and order. And right now, it's it's pretty dicey out there and to empower our police. But that being said, I realize that I you I think it was brought up I don't want to jeopardize the rest of the1:06:41 package by creating a a split on this council that may you know you know uh adversely affect the rest of the package [snorts] to be honest with you. I think you know there's other ways we could go and you know quite frankly that's another reason I would like to have a sit down with the general assembly and really hash this out with the presidents of the police chief and you know Patrick1:07:06 you and I had you know the discussion uh you know on this thing you know but once again I think what let's put in stuff in this package that is doable and focus on that and not have any distractions.1:07:21 Well, I'll tell you what. At this point, let's pass.1:07:23 Is everybody okay with us taking it out?1:07:25 Yes.1:07:28 That slide number.1:07:31 Slide number six.1:07:35 Vice Mayor, we're at number 19.1:07:38 Oh, thank you. Um, increase the penalties for prostitutions near a massage partner.1:07:47 Everybody okay with that one?1:07:50 Uh number 20, expand the circumstances when a court can temporarily prohibit disclosure of subpoenas, search warrants, and disclose closure orders.1:08:13 Any problem with that one?1:08:17 And that's all of those. And then we have the charter amendment. [snorts] Is anyone against the charter amendment?1:08:24 Barbara, well, I've had some people asking questions about this and [cough and clears throat] turns out they were coming along my lines. Um, I'm not so sure why we are wanting to do this. folks have been saying, well, what are y'all thinking about extending the services below the green line and that's why you're talking or below the blue line? And the thing of it is our policy now is that we will not extend1:08:52 water and sewer and these services below the blue line. Period. What we seem to be doing is providing a path to do that.1:09:01 And to get a supermajority is not that hard. I look at how fast we got a supermajority to approve the silo project.1:09:09 Uh super majority is not going to be any great thing. And I just think it looks like we're providing a pathway to do what we have said we were not going to do.1:09:23 Anybody else at this point?1:09:25 Well, this is any different than the one we passed last year and the Farm Bureau unanimously supported it. And these are the farmers down there. this is it's not creating a pathway to do it down there.1:09:37 It's just another wall of protection and and I think that's really it's it's kind of like trying to think there's some subversive reason for it but there's not. It's just to give another layer of protection down there.1:09:49 Well, I think it's just the way what you're thinking about is what people have been asking me about. Why are you doing this? And anyway, I'm just giving you my thoughts and I am uh I don't want people to think that a supermajority is going to stop it because we've very easily come up with supermajorities and I don't think that is really [clears throat] going to be a deterrent.1:10:16 Okay, Hutch and then Stacey. So, um, Miss Henley, I I think for me, I'm I'm I'm I'm kind of with what I think the vice mayor is trying to say is that I think we're trying to put it in there to be uh more uh to make sure that you had to have it.1:10:35 Yeah, of course we could we could get a a super majority from from anybody, you know, I mean, on any any issue if it was important enough, but I I feel like in what I've talked to my folks that work down there or live down there, that that's what we're trying to do is make it tougher to not not easier. But but I have to say it's this is one of the1:10:57 times where it's your district if if if you don't want it. I mean and you think their majority don't. But I think as the vice mayor just said, it sounds like some of the people were trying to help protect their rights or for it, you know, I mean helped help form it, right?1:11:14 Yeah.1:11:15 I just like the policy being we're not going to do it period.1:11:19 Yeah.1:11:19 Because that's the way the policy has been. We're not going to extend water and sewer.1:11:24 That's not that's not u we know that's a thought, but that's not reality.1:11:29 Well, okay. I'm just giving you my thinking.1:11:31 Yes, ma'am.1:11:32 Okay, Stacy.1:11:34 I perception is reality. And I understand, Miss Henley, that if people want to perceive this as being a sneaky way to get water and sewer below the green line, then education is going to have to be the cure for that. Because in my opinion, my understanding, this piece of uh legislative uh request comes from the purest of intentions with trying to give a piece of mind to the citizens1:12:11 that we [clears throat] never intend to go below the blue line. It codifies the blue line. It lets people know exactly what it is. And right now, we may have an agreement or we may have a policy that says we're not going to go below the blue line, but as we speak, it simply takes six people to disagree with that. this piece of legislation and putting it into our charter would require a supermajority and that's1:12:43 making a a more difficult pathway to doing something that none of us I don't believe have any intention of ever doing but a nine person threshold's a lot harder to get to than a sixperson threshold and again purest of intentions and I don't think there's anyone's intent here is to try to um create a pathway [clears throat] to developing south of the blue line. I think it's the exact opposite.1:13:17 Okay. Cash, Michael, and then Rosemary.1:13:23 [clears throat] Have your hand up.1:13:24 Oh, okay.1:13:25 Oh, I was waving, too.1:13:28 Best.1:13:30 Okay. Good [clears throat] discussion, guys.1:13:34 Um, no, Mr. Cummings basically said what I wanted to say, but let me let me just try to add to that. The pathway Mrs.1:13:42 Henley just described already exists, only it exists now with a six vote majority. So, if anyone were trying to be sneaky about anything, why would they make it more difficult to achieve that than less difficult the where it already stands?1:14:00 Doesn't make any sense. I think it undermines further undermines public trust and I don't know if that's intentional or unintentional and it doesn't matter but I think it does and there's no sneakiness here. If anyone were being sneaky they would leave it how it is which is only requires six. So that would be the most dumb sneaky person I've ever heard of. Um that just doesn't apply here.1:14:28 Okay. Well, I'm just relaying to you what I have been hearing.1:14:34 I appreciate the comments and it's dumb sneaky is I think it's the quote of the day.1:14:41 As good as needle.1:14:42 That's like needle leader.1:14:46 Yeah. Um, last year I brought this up and the reason I did it, it wasn't my idea. I'm not going to take credit for it. It was Barry Knight's idea. Delegate Barry Knight. He really wanted to see this in place to to send a strong message that the blue line really matters that we we want to keep the farmland. I mean, we've spent millions of dollars on ARP to protect the the1:15:12 farmland down there. And this puts in a another wall to make it even harder. And it's in our charter. It's not a policy.1:15:20 A policy can be changed like that. um and with six votes, the power of six.1:15:26 So, this will make it a lot harder and it's in our charter and to change our charter will be to have to go back to the general assembly. So, this is to protect our farmland and I I think it's a I think it's a good thing.1:15:40 Yeah. Let me just say this. One of the things that we have to honor and respect the agricultural community as a vital economic engine and part of our great city and this is going to give them assurance that it will remain that way.1:15:56 Does anybody else object? Let's go forward with it.1:16:00 Okay. That's I have one one point on um 19 the wording you have near massage parlor in uh just want to ask so the book correct so the point of this is for um any sort of instances of prostitution that takes um place near a massage parlor. Sometimes they are outside of the massage parlor itself within I think it's a th00and ft. I'm looking for help from my friends over here. Um I think it1:16:41 was within 1,000 ft is what the legislative language says.1:16:44 100 yards.1:16:44 100 yards. Okay.1:16:46 So could you say or in or not?1:16:50 Well, it includes within Yeah, it includes within um the language does. The request does [snorts] within where?1:16:59 It's in the longer document.1:17:02 Oh, it's in the longer I was just looking at this.1:17:05 Yes, ma'am. Sorry about that.1:17:06 Just said in Yes, ma'am.1:17:07 I mean, yes, ma'am.1:17:10 Okay. Thank you.1:17:12 Just quick question. Uh, Mr. McKenzie, on economic development page 16, uh, site readiness. Uh, do we still have that? Does the governor still have that program? Do we want to support that or was it taken away a year or two ago or um do we want to support it?1:17:28 This allows us to support it.1:17:29 It does. Yeah.1:17:31 Okay. Yes, sir.1:17:32 Thank you.1:17:34 Okay. Is that it?1:17:38 Is there anything else? Did we have Is there anything else? The addition that that's basically the core of it.1:17:48 Yes, sir. Mr. Mayor, that's the guidance we were looking for. I think that gives us everything we need. Although my friend and [snorts] successor Jesse has something.1:17:55 I just want to clarify that.1:17:59 I just want to clarify that this means that everything in one through nine, those general policy policies that are all in there, including the the the tree study that we talked about, um that will all be included in the legislative agenda since there seem to be consensus around all of that. So, I didn't want that that potential tree study that Miss Henley brought up to to be to for you1:18:18 all not to realize that it's still in the package. It's just not a separate minute. [clears throat] I have a question about the about what actually happens in Richmond. So, you can help me with that.1:18:28 What are you doing tomorrow?1:18:30 Motion to adjourn.1:18:34 Well, that's all very good. Um, but specifically in numbers 1 through nine, how do you decide on behalf of the city of Virginia Beach when to put your thumb on the scale for any or for or against any legislation as it comes up? Let's say there's, you know, a line for fiscal responsibility and budget um impacts. That's a very important line because we know affordability is top of1:19:03 mind of all residents across the country and in Virginia Beach. And um and then there's another environmental piece of legislation that might relate to us the the city of Virginia Beach. I mean I don't want to overstate because I know the legislators I mean I've heard anyway never mind. But I I don't know I don't know how much stock any legislator puts in a city legislative agenda in real terms. But1:19:30 but how do you decide? It's always been a mystery to me. Um because I do think that there is some credibility.1:19:36 Certainly the legislators reference it when it's when they want to um when it's in service to their promotion of their bill or whatever that a municipality supports or opposes that. But how do you decide when to put your thumb on the scale and at what direction? Uh so Councilman, historically what uh I've done and folks in my position have done is with these policy priorities, some of1:20:01 them are really specific like you know we support the site readiness program, we support um you know uh some of the um uh technology for speed cameras, things like that. Those are pretty generic and easy to decipher where the council has given us direction. Some of them are a little more generic as you mentioned on um dealing with uh like taxation or unfunded mandates and oftentimes you'll1:20:29 remember uh the person in my position comes before you every Tuesday and gives you an update on kind of what's happening in Richmond and I give you just slides of uh pieces of legislation and I have histo I have tried to kind of um uh put them in buckets based on the policy priorities and I'm telling you as I'm going along that, you know, we'd like to support this or we don't like1:20:54 this, we'd like to oppose that and then typically at the end of the my presentation, you guys give me that direction um whether I can or can't present Virginia Beach's position on that. So, we try to be um specific in some instances, sometimes it's generic, but we always try to make sure that we have your guidance and um you know uh as we make these decisions. I think you1:21:15 have done a good job of that, Brent. And I think there's but I've seen different through the years, even before I was on council, times where it worked really well and times where it didn't work really well. Um, but I think for for all of our sake, it's in good practice to be working in cohesion on those things. And I think you did a great job of keeping us in the loop. I I know um Miss1:21:37 Reynolds will as well, too. Uh it's really important because when we show up it I do think it carries weight and um and and it's really it's really important thing to be responsive to those things as they come up.1:21:53 Okay, Patrick, did you have something?1:21:54 I was just going to supplement to what um what Brent what1:22:08 But yeah, I mean as I think how much legislation came through session last year? Like 22,000?1:22:14 They were like 2500 legislation. Yeah.1:22:19 So we try to capture as much of it as possible, but there's some that we we end up missing because it's just too many for us to all process at the same time. But Brent's right. We typically try to give council a read ahead of what's going on. And then on Tuesday, the ones that are paramount that either our legislative um our delegates bring to us or that we see that'll be1:22:42 important for to get the council to weigh in on and give us direction on. We do try to cover them on the Tuesdays when the session starts to get your guidance and feedback.1:22:51 Okay. Anything else? Okay. Hey, thanks a bunch. Really appreciate it.1:22:55 Thank you. Appreciate the time.1:22:59 Make sure you leave your badge at the door.1:23:01 Okay.1:23:05 vanquished to the first floor.1:23:10 What's his name? [clears throat] Any liaison reports?1:23:16 Any discussions, initiatives? Jennifer, this past Thursday, the minority business council had its fall expo. So, council member Ross Hammond, Mike Leazison, and the mayor, we were all present. Um, and just a reminder, the the keynote speaker, um, Stephen Anthony, um, he does a number of events with our NBC and our Hive department, but he credited the city of Virginia Beach and on our investment in workforce1:23:42 development and economic development through the Hive, through the SWAM business office, and specifically through the NBC council. So, um, just want to congratulate that committee, um, the staff, the swam office, the hive business office, and, uh, my colleagues for a great event this past Thursday at the convention center.1:24:01 Yes. And we had a really great turnout.1:24:05 No, [snorts] it really was. Okay.1:24:07 Anybody else at this point?1:24:10 Is it council comments or council comments? Yeah. So last Thursday, some of you all uh colleagues uh attended the CVB's presentation on tourism economics study for the 2025 resort and uh the report I think was outstanding. Uh and very a lot of congratulations to a lot of folks especially our city staff. Uh but just let me go through the numbers real quickly from before. 14.4 million visitors visited this the city the1:24:37 resort area in 2025 spending $2.6 6 billion. That multiplies out when you expanded out to a little over $4 billion. When I started a few years ago, these numbers were almost half of this.1:24:51 Um almost 35,000 jobs to our citizens in the city of Virginia Beach. And like it or not, I I kind of like it. Uh the impact on our state and local [snorts] taxes, 30 it generates $352 million in state and local taxes. It's quite um a part of our city tourism and I told Iraq the resort advisory commission last week that we have a lot to be proud of in our1:25:16 city. We need to tell that story. The value of tourism is great and this report gives it to us. Thank you.1:25:23 Okay.1:25:24 Okay. We give them a thank you with our new snap your fingers. Yeah, that would be good. Yeah, there we go. Michael, I just want to take a minute. I know I'm going back a little ways, but we didn't meet last week. I want to talk about Halloween if I could. Uh the Plaza Rescue Squad hosted their 41st annual Operation Safe Haven Halloween where members of the squad uh came together to1:25:51 create a haunted house and an open house for the community and there were thousands of young people and families there. Um they serve every year. just can't believe how much candy and treats there are and how how much expertise and creativity they put into making the haunted house and how much of a really beloved um institution that is in in our part of the city in district 3. And to1:26:18 think that they've been doing that for 41 years in the same location is pretty amazing and pretty special. And and um I just want to recognize their hard work and thank them and thank them for including Cole and I Cole and me in in this year's efforts.1:26:33 We were able to volunteer, so that put a different spin on it. It was a lot of fun. So, shout out to them.1:26:39 Yeah, just um along the same lines, uh KVRS, Kim Volunteer Rescue Squad, uh had their their banquet the other night and the mayor and I attended it was their 75th anniversary. So, uh really really cool. Um [snorts] I have to say they've produced some fire chiefs in their time. So, uh, I started out as a 21-year-old kid, walked in the doors, and 13 hours later I was a volunteer, and a year later I1:27:06 was hired. Um, so a lot of good memories of Kimville and company nine, as we say. Um, they had lots of people from uh saw lots of people from old friends that we hadn't seen in a long time and they're a well-run organization and it's proud to be a part of it. Thanks for being there and reading the resolution and all. No, I was proud to do that. Uh, today is a1:27:30 little bit of a birthday of sorts.1:27:32 Everybody knows that my misspent youth was spent in the United States Marine Corps back in the day. And today we are celebrating the 251 first birthday of the United States Marine Corps. And I had the privilege the other day of attending uh you know the banquet and uh it was a magnificent ceremony that the assistant common down of the Marine Corps was there and I'll tell you what uh it just highlights how1:28:01 proud we are of our military presence right here in Virginia Beach. Often said that they are definitely the part of the DNA of what makes this city great. And we often say that we are Virginia Beach is a city of heroes. It's our military.1:28:19 It's our public safety folks. And and I'll tell you what, even some of the folks, the residents here that do incredible things every day, you know, we have a lot to be grateful. Okay. How about this thing called the consent agenda?1:28:36 It's a little lengthy today.1:28:39 Okay. Um, under resolutions, there's only one speaker on that you can support. So, does anybody have any issues with ordinances and resolutions?1:28:51 I didn't hear you say. What did you say?1:28:53 We had number one has one and one has one speaker.1:28:59 Mr. Mayor.1:28:59 Yes. Okay. Dana, I passed on a map. The agenda request and the ordinance for number six under section J is correct, but there was a map showing a different address. So I passed out a map that shows the correct address.1:29:12 Okay.1:29:18 Okay. Planning um number seven is going to be pulled. I don't think anybody's surprised at that. So then going back to number one, LBC Ventures and this time Oh, I'm sorry about that. Um, this is Hook Lane.1:29:37 Which one was this? I'm sorry.1:29:38 Number one, um, LBC Ventures.1:29:41 Hook Lane is fine for consent. [snorts] Okay. Number two, 449 London LLC, District 3.1:29:49 Vice Mayor, number two is fine for consent. And if I could, I just want to thank the applicant and I want to thank all of the um adjacent neighbors and property owners who work together to come up with agreeable path forward.1:30:07 It was a really good process and um we finally got there.1:30:12 That's going to be as amended. There are additional conditions that I guess the they will pass out to you all. Just want to make sure you call that that was agreeable.1:30:22 Okay. So until the last that will be as amended then.1:30:25 So it'll be as amended. Yes.1:30:28 Number three investments that is in district 4.1:30:33 Yes. Okay. I give consent.1:30:35 Okay. Number four um sector site power assets and that's in district 10.1:30:46 They're requesting deferral. So they they will come back when they're ready for us to consider.1:30:53 They're are they requesting another deferral or definite deferral?1:30:57 So when they're going to call us indefinite.1:30:59 Oh, indefinite. Okay.1:31:09 Okay.1:31:14 Number five. Oh, Jezeapina police and Marissa and that is in district one.1:31:26 Yes, ma'am. I'm going to uh talk to them or I've tried but we've got to have something. I don't plan on supporting that in the way it is right now. So, I'm going to tell them it' be best for a deferral. It's 12. I'm not looking for 12 kids. They've got total opposition all the way around it. It wasn't approved by planning. There's a pool. I just have like multiple things that1:31:47 don't make me feel good about this one.1:31:49 So, how long to [clears throat] defer till then?1:31:52 I'm I'm going to say indefinitely until 60 days or that's fine. Till they can work out that a better plan and I don't think they have any any experience either.1:32:03 You want to do indefinite?1:32:04 I mean, that's where I'm at. But sorry, I didn't hear inde I mean they can make that decision, right? Right. There you go.1:32:14 Just to clarify, they they changed the um number from 12 to 10.1:32:19 Not that I think that's going to change your mind, but thank you though for pointing that out, but Okay.1:32:24 Okay. Number six is Brandon Aetta and James Herrell and Associates LLC District 3.1:32:39 That's fine for concern.1:32:42 Seven is pulled. Eight is Zoe Malay.1:32:49 Uh, district 8.1:32:50 What's that?1:32:56 And number nine, 11 5112st Street, District 6.1:33:02 Consent, please.1:33:03 Number 10, Alexandra and Constance, District Six. consent, please.1:33:12 Okie dokie. Here we go.1:33:15 I just want to say something real quick.1:33:17 Go for it.1:33:18 We're going to do something starting today a little bit differently. Uh the staff has been looking across the region of other councils and how they do their consent agenda and they really have the either the clerk or the city manager read it and that's how they've been doing it. So, we thought we would try starting that today.1:33:38 Okay. Okay. So, Amanda will be reading the consent agenda. Okay. Going forward.1:33:43 All right. The chair will entertain a motion to recess into a closed session pursuant to this uh exemptions for open meetings allowed by section 2.23711A code of Virginia as amended for the following uh purposes. publicly held property. uh discussions or considerations of the acquisition of real property for real purposes or of disposition of publicly held property where discussions in an open meeting1:34:11 would adversely affect the bargaining position or the negotiation strategy of the public body and that is an acquisition district two legal matters consultations with legal counsel employed or retained by the public body regarding specific legal matters requiring the provision of legal advice.1:34:31 by such council pursu pursuant to section 2.2 3711A88 and that's the VB national purchase and development agreement and personnel matters discussion considerations or interviews of prospective candidates for employment assignment appointment promotion performance demotion salaries disciplining or resignation of specific public officers appointees or employees of any public body pursuant to section 2.23711A1 to 3711A11:34:59 and that's appointments of boards, commissions committees authorities agencies, and appointees. Do I have a motion? So move.1:35:06 Second.1:35:08 Council Luchi.1:35:09 Hi. Couns.1:35:11 Hi. Councley.1:35:12 Hi. Counc. Hi.1:35:13 Counc. Hi. Council.1:35:15 Hi. Councelor Ross. Hi. Council. Hi.1:35:18 Council member Schman. Hi. Vice [clears throat] Wilson. Hi. Mayor Dyer.1:35:21 Hi. 11.1:35:23 Okay. We are recessed into close. Thank you all very much.1:35:34 Okay. Good evening everyone. I'm going to call this meeting to order. And if you'd be so kind, if you're willing to stand for the invocation.1:35:47 Here we go.1:35:49 Heavenly Father, you are always with us and beside us. be with us this evening as we consider the affairs of our great city. Give us the patience to listen, the wisdom to decide, and the strength to act. Amen. And [snorts] if I may now ask for a moment of silence for all of those who paid the ultimate price to keep our city and our nation safe.1:36:22 Thank you. I pledge of allegiance.1:36:25 I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.1:36:42 Okay, madame clerk, do we have a roll call?1:36:45 Yes, your honor. All present.1:36:47 Okay. Do I have a motion for the certification of the close session?1:36:55 Okay.1:37:00 Who Who was the second? There we go.1:37:02 Hatch.1:37:05 The vote is open.1:37:09 Why is it not showing?1:37:10 Okay. At this point, do we have a Sorry. By a vote of 11 to zero, you've certified the close session be in accordance with a motion to recess.1:37:17 I apologize for that. Thank you. Um uh do we have a motion to approve the minutes of the informal and formal sessions of October 20th 26 and the formal session of October 27th, 2026?1:37:33 So moved.1:37:34 Second.1:37:40 The vote is open.1:37:45 By vote of 11 to zero, you approve the minutes as submitted.1:37:49 Thank you. Okay. At this point, uh, we're going to have the public hearing on the proposed charter amendment, land use and public system approval south of the blue line.1:37:58 We have any speakers?1:37:59 Yes, we have one speaker, Jane Bledworth Bworth Row.1:38:10 Jane Bworth Row.1:38:13 She is not responding.1:38:16 Okay. Uh at this point, let's do the consent agenda and we have a little change in format and city clerk. Are you okay?1:38:24 We have one speaker for um J1. So, do you want to do the Okay, I'll do the speaker script.1:38:32 Okay. I want to remind everyone that the city council speaker policy that allows certain representatives of groups to speak for for 10 minutes applies only only to planning items. All other speakers, whether speaking individually or on behalf of a group, will have up to three minutes to speak on a single item.1:38:53 Speakers are reminded that comments during the formal portion of the meeting must be limited to the subject of the item that is being considered by the council at the time you are called. For items placed on the consent agenda, a speaker will have up to three minutes to address any single item. [sighs] If a speaker wishes to address multiple consent agenda items, [snorts] the speaker will have a cumitive total of1:39:18 six minutes to address those items.1:39:22 Again, the speaker must limit his or her comments to the subject matter of the items that they have signed up to address. And finally, I call upon all speakers and all persons in the chamber to be civil in their discussion and decorum. Whatever views you hold and wish to express, the city council wants to hear from you. In order to ensure that all viewpoints and all persons are respected,1:39:50 clapping cheering booing speaking loudly or making other disruptive sounds while a speaker has the floor is not permitted. All speakers have the equal right to be heard. Any member of the audience who interferes with a recognized speaker's time will will be warned and if the disruptive behavior continues will be required to leave the chamber. Additionally, threats and intimidation of others is prohibited at1:40:20 all times.1:40:23 We have one speaker on ordinance J1 and that's Robert Cougler.1:40:32 Good evening.1:40:34 Good evening, mayor, vice mayor, all the members of the council. I'm going to divert just real quick and then I'll give my name and everything, but I'm only going to divert to say this is the last chance I'll have to speak.1:40:46 Can you hold up the microphone up a little bit? There we go.1:40:50 I should say I'm Robert Cougler. I live at 2084 Beer Drive, Virginia Beach, Virginia. And I've been here for 27 years. And my diversion is only to say this is the last chance I'll have to speak on behalf of Southshore Estates and all of you make our life so much wonderful. So you deserve a thanks and I want you to know that topic at hand. We we have an ordinance1:41:17 that we propose or that we support which is to reinstate the truck no trucks on Upton Drive. Upton Drive was it's been there a long time so I slightly misled the way I said it in my written but at the time that Lakes Shore uh excuse me [clears throat] at the time that our community was built land to expand Upton Drive in our neighborhood up to four lanes was provided1:41:48 at that time and this is back when Nemo Parkway was just being completed in that area. We were asked as a community did we want it to go to four lanes which it could or stay at two and we unanimously said please keep it at two. The reason was we didn't want Upton to become the throughway that bypasses General Booth.1:42:11 The city agreed with that kept it at two lanes and furthermore after that was complete they put up a no trucks on Upton for our area and we appreciated that.1:42:24 Sometime later up um General Booth was going through some major construction which is almost done at this point and at that point we think that's the reason the city took down the no truck sign. Our request that it be put up is because we have found that houses which are adjacent to Upton between Beers and Upton are shaken badly by the truck traffic. We think it's because the road1:42:53 is really not built to handle that level of vehicle. Consequently, those people that live there suffer from the vibrations. Of course, there's noise and also across the street from there are a couple of kids parks which are popular and we feel it's a safety hazard to have the trucks there unnecessarily.1:43:15 So overall, our request is please restore the no truck signs on Upton and and it runs really from the kids school, the elementary school down at Damneck where they would normally get on to the NMO Parkway where they would continue on their own way. So that's my formal request.1:43:38 Thank you very much, sir. Thank you for coming. If I could say something.1:43:40 Yeah, please. Um, Bob, I want to thank you for being such a good leader for your community and we will miss you in District 5, but please know you've always got a friend here.1:43:50 Well, thank you very much.1:43:52 And [snorts] thank you for coming, sir.1:43:55 Okay.1:43:57 Mayor, vice mayor, members of council, to be considered for your consent agenda tonight under ordinances J1, ordinance to amend city code section 21-202 prohibit truck traffic trucks and require signage of such prohibition on Upton Drive between Nema Parkway and Damne Neck Road. Requested by Mayor Dyer and Vice Mayor Wilson. Number two, ordinance to direct the city manager to use project funds and capital project1:44:24 number 1000730 traffic safety improvements five ray replace the Windsorwood subdivision identification sign that is requested by Vice Mayor Wilson and council members Cummings, Jackson Green, and Schulman.1:44:39 Number three, ordinance to authorize acquisition of 13,735 square ft of vacant land on Sharp Street from the Rodri McCrae Revokable Trust and authorize the city manager to execute all necessary documents, Ray improvements to adjacent city-owned properties and drainage purposes. Number four, ordinance to authorize acquisition of 12,99 square ft of property located at 1132 Kery Drive and authorize the city1:45:12 manager to execute all necessary documents. Ray, replace pump station for public utilities. Number five, ordinance to authorize temporary encroachments into a city into a portion of city-owned property known as Mil Mill Pond aka Bass Inlet and a 5-ft public drainage and utility easement located at 2941 Samb Benin Road. Ray maintain existing rip wrap, revetment and and timber pine and1:45:38 construct and maintain a timber floating pier, aluminum gangway, timber pier addition, timber pile, aluminum boat lift, and two jet ski floats. And that's in district two.1:45:50 Number six. This ordinance to authorize authorize temporary encroachments into a portion of a 20 foot and 30 foot city- owned drainage and utility easements located at 1288 Holly Road. Holly Point Road Ray. Maintain existing timber bulkhead, four 8ft timber piles, 48 in metal fence, portion of a pool house, wood shed, brick patio, and construct and maintain a wood deck and boat lift1:46:17 for existing piles. That's in district 8. Number seven, ordinance to extend the date for satisfying the conditions of the matter of Whitney W. Elliot Ray closure of one half of an unimproved unnamed alley adjacent to the rear of 218 55th Street, unit B. Number eight is ordinance to extend the date for satisfying the conditions of the matter of Matthew E. Manall and Robin A. Manall1:46:40 rate closure of an unimproved unnamed alley adjacent to the rear of 219 54th Street. Number nine, ordinance to accept and appropriate $425,224 from the cities of Chesapeake, Norolk, Portsouth, and Suffach to FY 2627 human services operating budget. Authorize 1063 $1636 local match and transfer $106,36 with the consolidated grants special revenue fund to the FY2627 human services operating budget rang Ray1:47:17 bring awareness resources and treatment services to address the opioid ep epidemic in Hampton Roads. Number 10, gracious ordinance to accept and appropriate $62,500 from the Virginia Department of Emergency Management to the FY2627 Fire Department operating budget. Ray purchase equipment to support technical rescue response and training activities.1:47:39 Number 11, ordinance to accept and appropriate $39,821 from the Virginia Department of Behavioral Health and Developmental Services to the FY2627 Human Services Operating Budget RA support substance abuse disorder services. Number 12, ordinance to accept and appropriate $14,810 from the Library of Virginia to the FY 2627 Library Department operating budget, Ray Professional Development.1:48:06 Number 13, ordinance to accept and appropriate $8,135 from the Virginia Department of Emergency Management to the FY2627 Fire Department operating budget ra purchase equipment to support hazmat res hazmat response. Number 14, ordinance to accept and appropriate $3,000 from the Virginia Department of Behavioral Health and Developmental Services to the FY2627 Human Services Operating Budget and1:48:33 authorize a $1,000 local match raise support the projects for assistance in transition from homelessness the path program.1:48:42 Number 15, ordinance to appropriate $157,764 from the fund balance of the Commonwealth Attorney forfeited asset assets special revenue fund to the FY2627 Comalth attorney operating budget raised purchase desktop printers and scanners. Number 16, ordinance to appropriate and transfer $1 million from the debt service reserve of water and sewer enterprise fund as payo funding to capital project number one327,1:49:11 pump station program 6 and appropriate and transfer $1 million from the debt service reserve of the water and zero enterprise fund as payo funding to capital project number 10685 water meters replacement program way water regarding ing water and sewer infrastructure improvements.1:49:33 Number 17, ordinance to transfer $500,000 from capital project one number one463 Virginia aquarium renewal and replacement 3 to capital project number 1000749 Virginia aquarium modification and transfer $500,000 from capital project number 10437 Virginia aquarium building and systems and facility infrastructure 2 to capital Project 1000749 Virginia crane modification ray retain architectural engineering design and1:50:10 consultation services.1:50:13 Okay. Open a public hearing on planning.1:50:16 Planning K number one LBC Ventures LLC for a variance to section 4.4B 4B and D of the subdivision regulations rate deficiencies and required lot width, street line frontage, and lack of direct access to public street at 4716 Hook Lane. And that's in district 9.1:50:36 Number two, and this will be as amended, 449 London LLC for conditional change of zoning from R10 residential district to conditional I1 light industrial district. Ray developed site with storage yard for contractor's vehicle vehicles, equipment and materials and a conditional use permit Ray bulk storage yard at 2548 Potters Road District 3.1:51:01 Number three is VB Investments LLC, BNL Investment Group LLC for a conditional change of zoning from B2 Community Business District conditional A18 apartment district reconstruct a 23 unit town homestyle condominium development at 700 and 700 724 Baker Road and that is in district 4 number four and this is the applicant is requesting indefinite deferral.1:51:31 Sector Site Tower Assets LLC, Sector Sight Towers Assets LLC, Great Eastern Resort Corporation, and Vicinity Holdings LLC for a conditional change in zoning from O2 Office District to conditional B2 Community Business District and a conditional use permit Ray Mini Warehouse and a conditional use permit Ray Bulk Storage at 3386 and 3396 Holland Road and that is in district 10 and again that is for1:52:02 indefinite deferral. Number five will be pulled and to be heard separately.1:52:08 Number six is Brandon I I sorry James Harold and Associates LLC for conditional use permit Ray Tattoo Parlor and a conditional use permit Ray Body Piercing Establishment at 481 South Linhaven Road District 3. Number seven will be pulled for separate consideration as well. Number eight is Zoe Malay Ducas for a conditional [clears throat] use permit Ray residential kennel at 3012 Edinburg1:52:40 Drive district 8. Number nine is 51121st Street LLC for conditional use permit rate short-term rental at 51121st Street. That's in district 6. And finally, lastly, number 10, Alexander and Constance Mening and Archon Investments Virginia LLC for a conditional use permit raise short-term rental at 4142nd and a half street and that's in district 6.1:53:09 My goodness. Thanks. Thank God for consent agenda.1:53:14 Second, do we have a mo did we have any? I can't make the motion. So, did you will someone make a motion?1:53:23 We did that.1:53:24 Okay. Who made the I'm sorry, I didn't I made the motion and worth made the Thank you so much. Vice Mayor made the motion. Mr. Rick, thank you. The vote is open.1:53:34 [sighs] By a vote of 11 to zero, you have have approved your consent agenda.1:53:42 Okay, we're going to move on to planning item number five. Jeppe Pes and Marissa Corsel Eugino Corsel for a conditional use permit of family daycare 99 Harvest Drive.1:53:57 The applicant is Marissa Corsel. if you'll come down.1:54:09 Hello.1:54:13 Good evening, mayor and members of city council. My name is Marissa and I'm here regarding my proposed home daycare, Milliey's daycare. First, I want to acknowledge the concerns that have risen by some of my neighbors, particularly regarding traffic, noise, and overall impact on our neighborhood.1:54:29 [gasps] I completely understand the concerns. As a homeowner, a mother myself, I value having a peaceful, safe, and family oriented neighborhood. [clears throat] Um, our days will follow a consistent routine with purposeful educational activities, small group learning, and supervised outdoor play. I also want to emphasize that this daycare is something I am personally invested in, and this is1:54:54 my childhood home and the community where I'm raising my daughter. I have every reason to ensure that the business operates respectfully and responsibly. I have several years of experience working in a monastery classroom and I understand the importance of structured supervision structure supervision and creating calm learning environment.1:55:12 I recognize that opening a daycare in a residential neighborhood comes with responsibilities and I'm committed to maintaining open communication with my neighbors and addressing concerns if they arise. Ultimately, our goal has never been to disrupt the neighborhood, but rather to create a small structured monastery inspired learning environment that blends natural that blends well with the community. Um,1:55:38 my parents owned a restaurant um in Chemville. It was called Puchinella and we proudly served the community for many years. Growing up, I saw firsthand the importance of hard work, building relationships, and giving back to the people around us. these those values have stayed with me and I hope to carry them on to Milliey's daycare. So, thank you. Any questions?1:56:03 So, if I understand it, you went from 12 to 10. Is that what you did? Um, yes, sir.1:56:11 And [snorts] then this is going to be your some of your children and then additional children. Is that what we're Yes. I have a 15-month old daughter and um so there would be additional children, right? Okay. So, we've had significant um opposition. Obviously, I have be honest with you, I've never seen this amount of around it, you know. Um so, I'm going to ask you to defer and that1:56:37 we can work um together as a group and and maybe come to a little better uh conclusion. Um it's uh we talked about it indefinite deferment. to get time to get it to get it right or to where everybody's more comfortable probably lowering the number. I'm not telling you what you got to do. I'm just telling you I learned that lesson. So, uh so you know, just something to think about, but1:57:01 I can be in part of it if you want or and I don't have to be if you don't want. So, absolutely. I would take any help.1:57:06 Okay. Um yeah, and I think uh Council Member Luchi wanted to say something.1:57:11 I did. Thank you. Uh thank you, Council Member. Mayor, if it's okay, like I just ask a couple questions. Um [clears throat] [snorts] I wasn't aware of the opposition so this is new to me. I have a question first for our planning director if that's okay. Could you would you mind um Miss Moss describing the nature of the opposition you received or anyone who's best yeah I'm going to ask staff to address1:57:36 this question since they're intimately involved with the details.1:57:40 The opposition we received was mostly related to traffic, the number of new cars in the neighborhood as well as noise from the use.1:57:48 Sorry, traffic cars. Same thing to me.1:57:52 Parking I guess and and noise and noise and then I was uh about the number of children was was what I received the number. Yeah.1:58:03 Um the applications we were and let me tell you why I'm asking these questions.1:58:10 And I have some questions for you too, ma'am. Um, child child learning and child care affordability is one of the most pressing issues that faces Virginia Beach families and we have to responsibly. So, I credit you uh, [snorts] Council Member Hutcherson for making sure we get it right. But we have to um proactively seek solutions to create child care and child learning opportunities for Virginia Beach1:58:41 families and young people. And I see that you're trying to do that here. One of the most affordable ways to achieve that is through those inhome um operations like what you're proposing.1:58:55 And so I want to try to get to a solution here. That's very it's very much on my mind.1:59:00 I talked to people across district 3 and across the city and one of the most significant issues they face as a young family is child care and quality child learning opportunities for their families. It's it's something that we we have to find solutions toward and um and I I know you're committed to the same.1:59:22 So may I ask the other question is you're applying for 12.1:59:28 So, under licensing, which is what the route we are going through, the max is 12. I never really wanted 12 because that just seems too much for me. Um, but um when we when I had the planning committee speak last time, we um suggested 10, which I felt comfortable with. Um [laughter and clears throat] I'm sorry, I lost your question.1:59:53 Yeah. Well, and part of my question is also to our professional staff, what's the standard? In other words, like for these types of applications, what are you usually seeing? Is it do they apply for the max or is it mostly six or whatever?2:00:07 Most of the time folks request the max at 12, but the maximum is set by the Department of Education. It's never more than 12, but if they apply for 12 here, then the Department of Education could approve them for up to 12. And the ages that you're contemplating is 0 to four.2:00:25 Two to five.2:00:26 Two to five. Um do you have help?2:00:30 I do. My mother and then I spoke to um a not a retired teacher. She just became a new mother. So she's taking time off from teaching and she's interested in working with us.2:00:42 So your mother does your mother does your mother live there or she'll be there during the operating hours?2:00:48 It's in my mother's home. Oh, it's in your mother's home.2:00:51 So, so you don't So, you will both be there at all times during operating hours, the two of you.2:00:57 Is that part of the lensure?2:00:59 Yes. So, we're following um licensing and I believe my mother, it's because it's under my because it's my mother's house, she has to be there a majority of the time. I believe she can take like a few hours off every day, but I will be there all the time. And pardon me. Is it your residence as well or you live in a different residence?2:01:20 I live in a different residence.2:01:21 A different residence. Um and then you're con you're considering hiring another an additional person.2:01:29 Considering. Yes.2:01:32 So you'll these are things probably we'll we'll work through with later application. And it's I'm asking questions because I'm learning [clears throat] too. No, you're I'm learning too. How the lensure works and and all that. Um, okay. You're willing to work with council member Hutcherson on these because I mean I think you're doing it seems like you're doing a really great thing and um and and I would like to get2:01:55 to a place where and I know uh council member Hutcherson would as well where where uh he feels comfortable and we all feel comfortable. I guess the concern that I have um with regard to the opposition and I don't want to not familiar with exactly what street you live on and and what that is. I know that uh your district representative is um but 10 or 12 families coming at2:02:22 different times. I know there would be a range, but that's not a substantially large impact of traffic. And the community benefit is is could be enormous even for those 12 families you would serve or or could be multiple young people from the same family. But, you know, however many families that is, that's I hope hopefully affordable options um for a family. That's something that's really important. And2:02:47 so I don't see uh the traffic or temporary parking as being a substantial impediment to something that has such a large community benefit. So I hope we can I hope we can all work together sort of quickly on this to resolve these things and and work through this. And I I almost wonder if it would be a great opportunity for a council briefing so that we could learn a little bit more2:03:10 about what lensure and the process for um for these uh what is it called exactly in home what what number daycare family daycare home family daycare home.2:03:27 Okay. Um, I think it would be great to have maybe a briefing about what the process is for that and how the state interplays with that so that we can all be on the same page for future applications because it is a it is a very important public policy discussion we have to have here in Virginia Beach.2:03:44 Thank you.2:03:45 Thank you. Anybody else? Yeah, let me say I know your family very well. I've been to the restaurant a number of times and I know you're a loving, caring family. You know, if there's a way to get to Yes. And I concur with Michael and if there's one guy can do it and that's Chief Hutch. Okay. Thank you.2:04:01 Thank you so much.2:04:06 Do we [clears throat] have to vote on it?2:04:07 No, we need a motion in a second.2:04:12 Uh [clears throat] make make a motion to to defer indefinite deferral and so we can work out the the parameters of everything.2:04:19 Okay.2:04:20 Second.2:04:25 There's a motion.2:04:26 Yeah. Defer.2:04:27 The vote is open and that is for indefinite deferral.2:04:32 Excuse me. By vote of 11 to zero, this application has been deferred indefinitely.2:04:37 Okay. Thank you. And then moving on to the next item, uh, real estate pursuits of, uh, LC BIVI Real Estate LLC for conditional use permit, Ray Mini Warehouse at 941 Alaskan Road, District 6.2:04:54 The first speaker is Tyler Rosa and he's the attorney representing the applicant.2:05:05 Uh, good evening, Mayor Dyer, Vice Mayor Wilson, members of the city council. My name is Tyler Ros. I'm an attorney with the law firm Williams Mullen here tonight on behalf of the applicant and the project, the shops at Alaskan Road.2:05:16 Um, over the past several months, we've worked closely with staff in the community on this application. We held two public meetings um and deferred the application to engage further with the community and staff. Um, prior to the planning commission, we submitted updated plans in response to the comments we were receiving from the city and the community. Um, the updated plans were submitted right around the2:05:39 publication of the staff report. They were not made into the staff report for the planning commission, but those were submitted and reviewed by staff and they are referenced in the city council narrative in the staff report this evening. Um, so there's updated plans.2:05:53 We, uh, modified the color scheme and look of the building to have more coastal inspired tones to better fit in with the resort area and the oceanfront corridor. We added an additional 2,000 ft of retail to bring the overall ground floor retail piece of the property to 8,000 ft². And uh, there was a slight move in the subdivision line in response to comments from the city fire department that were shown on those2:06:16 plans. Um and the despite the um staff findings in the uh staff report, we do believe that the use is consistent with the comprehensive plan. Um the staff report recommendation recommendation relies on two primary conclusions. Uh first that the self storage use does not align with the vision of the resort SGAA and second that the resort that the self storage use does not align with the goal2:06:38 of the Alaskan road corridor. Um the report says that the vision for the resort SGA is for buildings to have an active engaging and pedestrianoriented frontage and we believe this project meets that vision. Uh there's 8,000 square ft of retail targeting a variety of tenants. There's a high-end design and architecture to the building and we have a proposed multi-use path along Alaskan Road for the project. Um the2:07:04 report further acknowledges that the project's thoughtful design quote works to create a more active street facing edge as recommended by the comprehensive plan. Uh the resort the report further says that the goal of the Alaskan road corridor is to serve as a gateway to the oceanfront for both residents and visitors and we believe we meet this goal as well. We're taking a vacant parking lot and converting it into a2:07:25 modern class A office building, a commercial building with attractive design and retail um uses. It's purposely designed not to look like a storage facility. It will look like a class A commercial building with groundf flooror retail. There will be minimal signage along the lower part of the building. Um this only storage signage would be above the retail office and the loading would be in the back of the2:07:49 building and would not be visible from Alaskan Road. Um the project's also consistent with the business use special place type. Um the goal of which is to provide attractively designed setting for groups and businesses and service uses and to provide services for surrounding local communities. Uh to quote a staff report from a recently approved uh facility in the corridor, uh quote, "The storage facility will2:08:11 provide a service for surrounding businesses and residences, and we believe this facility will as well with an additional retail component." Um and the city has found similarly situated facilities in this corridor to be consistent with the comprehensive plan with the same zoning profile as this uh property. Um and although our property is being considered under the new comprehensive plan, both new2:08:34 comprehensive plan and the prior comprehensive plan have similar goals related uh for the resort SGA regarding the unique sense of arrival and pedestrianoriented uh environment. So we believe that uh this project is substantially similar in terms of comprehensive plan compliance uh with the additional pedestrian um and retail component to it. So, not only do we believe this is a consistent use, we2:08:57 believe that it is the highest and best use for this property based on the zoning restrictions and de development limitations on this property, uh the uses on this property are restricted by the underlying zoning district and the overlay districts that are imposed on the property. The property is in the B2 zoning district and covered by the AQS and the APZ overlays. And uh those limitations um eliminate a variety of2:09:21 other uses that have been discussed and suggested for this site as either um not permitted or inconsistent and not compatible with those zoning restrictions um including multif family residential high-capacity uses, hospitals, nursing homes, daycare facilities. And further, the unique shape of the parcel also constrains development of the of the property. It's in a regularly shaped parcel uh2:09:42 constraints building placement, access, and parking layout. So, the self- storage with a ground floor retail, 8,000 ft of ground flooror retail is one of the few viable uses that satisfies the underlying base zoning requirements and the overlay districts as on a compatibility basis. Um, and also maximizes the value and the tax revenue for this property. Um there's been a lot of discussion about traffic on this2:10:08 property, not only with respect to this application, not necessarily this application, but prior applications and development considerations for this property. And uh this use would reduce traffic on this site by 65% from the prior movie theater use. Uh the average renter of a unit uses a unit and visits a unit approximately once per month. So this would be a low traffic generating use for this site. Um during our2:10:31 community meetings there were questions and comments regarding the environmental impacts of this project. Um so the applicant during the deferral period uh conducted an environmental impact study.2:10:42 Uh that study found that there would be no impacts to the wetlands, the RPAs, storm water, threatened or endangered species. Um and uh overall the project will reduce the overall imperous surface of the parcel and improve the storm water quality and treatment for the storm water on the site. Um there's also questions about the need for another storage unit um in this area. And the market demand and analysis for a2:11:08 facility like this is generally done on about a 2-m radius. And when you look at within that 2-m radius from the property, there's a number of new multif family senior housing infill developments that have been proposed or recently approved. Um, and there's a transient military population and a seasonal visitor demand and also small businesses make up approximately 20% of the users for these type of facilities.2:11:32 Um, additionally, a lot of the facilities in the area are a bit older and they don't have the current modern amenities for these type of uh that this type of facility will have. And so, we anticipate coming online um at a time where we'll be able to meet that market demand. And some of the other facilities may be leased up or close to being leased up at the time that this would2:11:52 come online. So, um in conclusion, we believe this is a great project for this property representing its highest and best use. Uh, it's a class A commercial building purposely designed not to look like a storage facility. You will drive by it and you will not know it's a storage facility. It will look like a commercial building with ground flooror retail. Um, it's consistent with the2:12:12 zoning restrictions, the comprehensive plan and the city precedent for similar facilities in this corridor. Uh, so we would request a recommendation of or we would request approval of this application with a few modifications to the uh conditions in the staff report. I believe on your dis um I provided you with what our suggested and requested proposed conditions would be. Largely2:12:33 there' update the dates on the plans to reflect the current plans that were submitted to the city prior to planning commission but they didn't make it into the conditions. So we would be updating the dates on conditions 1, 2, and three.2:12:47 And then condition five, also during a deferral period, we had a discussion with staff regarding and there's been a lot of discussion regarding the proposed multi-use path and the environmental impacts. It's in a very environmentally sensitive area. There are a lot of utilities and public infrastructure in that area. We're committed to uh building that multi-use path, but also want to make sure that there is2:13:08 flexibility if there is adverse environmental impacts in city infrastructure. So the that would be the scope of the request and I'm happy to read those into the record. Um so the change for condition one would be to change the date from June 24th, 2026 to September 2nd, 2026. Uh change on condition two would be to change the date from June 24th, 2026 to September 2nd 2026.2:13:34 The condition uh condition three, the change would be to change the date from July 27th, 26 to August 27th, 2026.2:13:41 again reflecting all the dates of the revised plans that were submitted before planning commission. And then on condition five would be to add language at the end of that condition uh quote unless the director determines such facility would result in material adverse environmental impacts and adverse impacts to existing infrastructure and surrounding property.2:13:59 So we would request a approval with those amended conditions. Um thank you for your time and consideration. I'll stand by for any questions. Have the development team and the owner here as well. Thank you, Mayor D. Thank you, Mr.2:14:11 Rosa, for the presentation. Uh, could you for the benefit of the of the council and the public go through the timeline because this was the movie theater, 4.2 acre site, zone B2 that's been on the market as a 4.2 twoacre site movie theater and then a really cool podel padel facility or operator out of Richmond bought the site and then is now creating a podel facility there now in the former movie theater. Can you go2:14:40 through the the timeline because that closed I think as a matter of public record to the podel operator out of Richmond in March 23rd of this year 2026.2:14:51 So to go from 4.2 two acres down and this is maybe an acre and a half or so that's on the agenda tonight for for the application. Can you confirm all of that? So a closing in March of this year and then this parcel which is a different parcel than the larger one went on the market then which is March and then that's under contract. So then you've had maybe four, five, six months2:15:14 of marketing this particular property to the world and here we are with self storage.2:15:20 Yes sir. And I actually have um a representative from Dvarus um to speak to the marketing efforts and the property owner here as well to speak to kind of the marketing efforts. I have kind of the limited visibility into what I've been involved in, but the general timeline that you're laying out um is consistent with my understanding too. So in early in um beginning of this year, the uh Padell facility received a use2:15:45 permit to remodel the um beach cinema site into that facility. There is a plan that subsequently the property has been subdivided and this side of the uh property is being developed into this project. Um, from what I understand on the marketing efforts, I would probably defer to Dvarus and the property owner to speak to that and I'm happy to um, defer to them if you'd like to have that answered right now.2:16:11 Could we I'm sorry, mayor. I just want to make sure you understand. We have multiple speakers.2:16:15 Yeah, we have multiple speakers on this item. So, we'll get if you'd like to call them up um to speak to those. I believe the DVAR representative is signed up to speak. I don't know if the property owner as well, but please feel free to call them up.2:16:28 Yeah, we'll get that worked out.2:16:29 Okay. Okay. Thank you.2:16:30 Okay. Anybody else? Okay. Thank you for now.2:16:33 Thank you very much.2:16:34 The next speaker is Katherine Campbell.2:16:40 After Miss Campbell will be Chris Fuller.2:16:44 This is just to keep my time.2:16:54 Hello. Hello. My name is Katherine Campbell. I live at 8302 Atlantic Avenue. I'm here to speak in opposition to this use. Um, when city council makes an exception for a special use, there must be compelling reasons to do so.2:17:10 There are many byright uses available to a developer, all of which have been carefully vetted and chosen as appropriate for the district. This use has no compelling reasons. It's not appropriate for this location. Mini warehouse has no impact on economic development. It will add one or two jobs. It has none of the sales tax revenues that a buy B2 use could generate and no boost to tourism. Just2:17:36 the opposite. Tourists aren't coming here to rent a storage unit. This they're coming for a resort experience.2:17:43 That's what we should be giving them in this location. One block west. Oh shoot, I forgot to do this. One block west, Birdneck Road and Oral to from Bernest Road, Birdneck Road to Oral Drive, there are two massive self-s storage units to welcome tourists. There are two big box auto repair tire stores to welcome tourists. This block between Oral Drive and the roundabout is really like a transition from that2:18:10 commercial corridor to the gateway where the city council spent $40 million taxpayer dollars to create a vibrant pedestrianfriendly welcome for the tourist and for and for the residents. That's the entrance to our neighborhood.2:18:28 This transition block features low-profile structures, most dating from the 60s, that are not likely candidates for any kind of massive redevelopment because of their small lots, the required setbacks, and wetlands. Meaning this transition from the commercial to the resort can remain a transition depending on today's decision. This property in question for the mini warehouse is a sole candidate for redevelopment.2:18:58 But it should not be a mini warehouse.2:19:00 First of all, there's nothing mini about it. It's four stories. It's an extra story higher than the ocean storage in the previous block.2:19:11 They have described in their application disguising it with hardy board, faux window, steel canopies, very nice things. But you know the old saying, you put lipstick on a pig, it's still a pig.2:19:25 a very big fourstory pig and none of my neighbors want and I hope you've been getting emails in that regard.2:19:34 Many warehouse developments are popping up in B2 zones all over Virginia Beach, much to the horror of residents. They're a cash cow, high rents and low operating expenses. Maybe, you know, they can't find other uses for the property, then don't buy it. But many storage is not the use. and whether people need whether whether they could fill it or not.2:19:56 Thank you very much. I appreciate you coming.2:19:58 Okay. Thank you. I hope you'll vote no.2:20:01 The next speaker is Chris Fuller.2:20:07 After Mr. Fuller is Jackie Schilbert.2:20:12 [snorts] Good evening.2:20:16 Hey, good evening, mayor, vice mayor, city council members. My name is Chris Fuller. I'm a vice president with Dvaris Real Estate based in Virginia Beach. Um I appreciate the opportunity to speak with you guys tonight and regarding the proposed red redevelopment of 941 Alaskan Road. Um I wanted to offer some perspective on the commercial real estate side particularly regarding the property's history, the efforts that2:20:44 have been made to identify alternative uses and some of the challenges we've encountered along the way. Um, first I think it's really important to understand the history of the property.2:20:54 Um, as I understand it, the property was originally developed in 1961 as a sand and surf hotel before eventually being redeveloped into a movie theater. The property has been a movie theater for about the last 30 years. Um, within that time, it's gone through several separate financial failures with three different operators. Uh, one of the long-standing challenges was the property access.2:21:21 Without a signalized entrance, managing the volume of vehicles entering and exiting the site, particularly when multiple movie showings are ending at the same time, prove very difficult. Um, following the theaters struggles, there was uh, efforts to identify replacement uses, including another theater operator and more recently a church. The church was ultimately withdrew its proposal2:21:44 following opposition and the property was once again left without a long-term solution. I bring that history up. I think it's important to recognize that the challenges we're discussing tonight um are not new. This property has struggled for many years to find a use that was both appropriate for the location and sustainable over the long term. So that brings me to my marketing effort. So, Dvarus has2:22:08 uh managed marketing this property for more than 5 years um with the current ownership and then also the previous ownership. I personally have been involved in the property since August of 2025 when my client uh placed the property under contract and I was directed to uh find tenants and developers. Uh we explored a long range of different uses. Um to give you guys some perspective, we've approached2:22:35 groups, national groups such as Texas Roadhouse, First Watch, Culver's, Dutch Bros, Cooper Hawk in North Italia. Also reached out to some wellestablished local restaurants, uh including groups associated with Waterman, Shore Break, Bay Local, Luche, Bakers Crust, and others. All those are real conversations, real efforts that we had.2:22:58 Um, and it was simply uh business we thought it wasn't just simply businesses that we thought were going to be appropriate for the property. Those were real efforts, real conversations that happened. Um, the challenges that we faced was first access. I mentioned the light um prior, but the absence of a signalized entrance at this particular property creates challenges.2:23:20 Thank you very much. Appreciate you coming.2:23:25 The next speaker is uh Jackie Schielberg and then Melissa Lucasen.2:23:35 Good evening.2:23:40 All right. Good evening, Mr. Mayor and Virginia Beach City Council. My name is Jackie Shelberg and I am a resident of Virginia Beach for 25 years and I've also had a business in in our city for over 15. I've already been here for round one of the permitting process which was denied. And at that time we had a petition online um started to deny this for all the residents in Virginia Beach community that did not want2:24:07 another storage facility on our street with over 2,000 signatures that was submitted. Then we also had hundreds of emails sent to city council to say we do not want a storage facility in our backyard. We don't want a fourstory metal 880 unit storage facility in our backyard.2:24:28 I've lived in Woodbury Forest apartment behind this um movie theater where they're uh proposing to build a site and we have salt metal marsh is right behind us. All around us, we have ducks, geese, herring, wildlife. I have peeled off more turtles off my street on Oral Circle since we allowed ocean storage another permit in the last 2 years. Like the other woman had said, the two ocean2:24:57 storage facilities are less than a they're two stop lightss apart. We we don't need another storage facility.2:25:03 There's vacancies. There's 71 storage units currently in the city of Virginia Beach that have vacancies. I'm sorry you might have to drive three miles to get there instead of two, but please understand we care about the wildlife.2:25:21 Um, [clears throat] I'd also like to say that because it's been a parking lot since 1972, we need to do more impact studies. They did not have an environmental impact study in the permit process and then they came up with one in 30 days which I don't know how that's possible. Um I'd also like to talk a little bit about thinking about going green. Why are we not asking for green building material2:25:46 materials in the city of Virginia Beach?2:25:48 Energy effective designing land native landscaping trees permeable surface and building designs to withstand the hotter temperatures that are coming. Not a metal storage unit. Increasing weather challenges and conditions for our coastal community is coming. It's already here. Climate change is real and the and the Virginia Beach is already planning for extreme heat, flooding, and sea level rising. The city's own 20402:26:13 comprehensive plan calls for environmental sustainability, improved flood and sea level rise, resiliencies, wildlife habitat security, ecoiversity, and greater public enjoyment of nature.2:26:27 None of these things are that. This is an opportunity to speak for the animals and also to go along with your projected plan to put something there that's in alignment of an eco-friendly family diverse vision.2:26:43 Thank you very much. Appreciate your comment.2:26:46 The next speaker is Melissa Lucasen.2:26:49 After Miss Lucasen is Ross Vieira.2:26:52 Hey Melissa.2:26:53 Hello.2:26:55 Good evening. council.2:26:57 Tonight, we are presented with yet another storage facility because apparently what Virginia Beach desperately needs is another place for people to store Christmas decorations and furniture they don't want to throw away. [snorts] At what point does this council stop and ask, "What are we doing to this city? Storage units, car washes, more storage units, more car washes. The [snorts] corner of my street, we have a2:27:22 car wash. Is this our economic development strategy? Turning Virginia Beach into a giant strip mall with garage doors. This proposal is in district 6 where I live. Our elected representative, Mr. Worth Remick, opposes it. The staff planner recommended denial. Our planning commission recommended denial. Last week, voters reelected Councilman Remick with 64% of the vote. While that2:27:45 election was not a rep a referendum on a storage facility, the people of district 6 have made a very clear decision about who they want to represent their interests. So, let's talk about flooding. 2021, more than 72% of Virginia Beach voters approved a 567.5 million uh flood protection bond referendum and more than a half a billion dollars to address flooding in this city. And yet here we are2:28:11 considering another development bordering wetlands. Wetlands aren't vacant lots waiting for developers to discover their profit potential, their natural infrastructure that helps absorb storm water and protect our communities.2:28:24 You ask taxpayers to spend more than half a billion dollars fighting flooding while you continue to treat the natural systems that help prevent flooding as irrelevant or disposable. And that's not responsible planning. and I'd like to know what storm water protections are being required for this property. Before council approves another development adjacent to wetlands, can someone answer2:28:42 whether this property requested relief from our storm water requirements, what that relief entails, and how approval [clears throat] would be consistent with the flood protection commitments taxpayers are already paying for.2:28:56 Because taxpayers shouldn't have to keep writing checks to fix problems that irresponsible development decisions [clears throat] make worse. Virginia Beach has a natural beauty and little by little we are replacing that character with the most unimaginative development.2:29:10 I'm tired of watching the city confuse development with progress because they're not the same thing. If you envision if you v if your vision for Virginia Beach is a storage unit on every corner in a car wash across the street, congratulations. You're turning a beautiful coastal community into a city of mediocre land use. I'm not asking you to stop progress. I'm asking you to develop some standards for what2:29:33 progress looks like in this city. Thank you.2:29:36 Thank you for coming.2:29:39 The next speaker is Ross Vieira. He's the last speaker before the attorney for the applicant comes back.2:29:48 Hey, Ross.2:29:48 Good evening. Good evening.2:29:51 Good evening, Mayor Dyer, Vice Mayor Wilson, and members of city council. My name is Ross Fier. I'm a lifetime Virginia Beach resident.2:29:58 [gasps] I'm a veteran and I'm a Virginia Beach business owner who lives right here in the Bernneck Point community right in the corridor in district 6. I also am the owner of Vieier Group and Vieira Construction and I'm very familiar with this type of construction and I'm very proud of our company and the history we have had in the community. I also believe this is the right project for2:30:17 this location along Alaskan Road. The comprehensive plan asked this quarter to deliver an attractive, engaging, pedestrian-friendly gateway. But that's what this project, the Shopsat Alaskan with its retail front-facing vision, brings to life. As you saw in the design, a class A style building with a coastal pallet, storefront reflective glass running along the length and height of this building, coastal2:30:42 awnings, warm lighting, and monument signage instead of a billboard, fresh landscaping, and a new pedestrian walkable sidewalk out front creates and brings 8,000 new square footage of retail street facing shops and a gathering spot for our neighbors and visitors to enjoy a high level of energy. The plan calls for your own staff report actually says this design creates that active street edge. The2:31:08 comprehensive plan recommends what makes this design economically possible is the climate control storage which only loads from the rear and is out of sight from Alaskan road. That's the economic engine that pays for the high-end architecture, the 8,000t of retail and the street stapes that'll make the Alaskan corridor beautiful. Without it, the site remains what it's been for decades, an empty2:31:34 parking lot along Alaskan Road. We're in APZ2, the highest noise zone and crash zone where hotels, housing, and developments and assemblies assembly uses cannot go. The storage use is a quiet, compatible use with Oceanana and low traffic. It generates 75% fewer daily trips than the zoning already allows by right. It serves our military families, folks that live in the new apartments nearby, and storage also2:31:59 serves the small business community and the requirements and storage needs that they have. This design and development also is good for the environment as it reduces the paved service area that already exists today, which this will be built on. It also treats storm water before it reaches the marsh instead of letting it run along an old parking lot.2:32:18 It's a $20 million plus investment in our community that supports 90 to 135 local construction jobs. Most of them are our trades people and our subcontractors right here in Virginia Beach and Hampton Roads. Permanently, that brings 30 to 40 40 permanent jobs once it's all open. Adding many new tax revenue streams of income to the city that almost demands no city services.2:32:43 The conditions for this bring architectural character. 8,000 foot of retail, new landscaping, pedestrian friendly sidewalk, which we want here on last.2:32:53 Appreciate your comments.2:32:54 Thank you so much.2:32:58 The applicant, the attorney for the applicant, if you like to come back up for rebuttal.2:33:07 [sighs] Um, so appreciate all the comments and discussion. Um, just hit on a few points. Um, so with respect to the other uses and obviously some of the comments were asking about having different uses on this property, whether this was the best use for this property as we've discussed the options and development restrictions and zoning requirements or limit the potential other uses for this2:33:33 property. So, and the conversation about this just being a storage facility, I think it misses that this is a mixeduse development with ground flooror retail.2:33:43 It will have high-end architectural design. It will be a visi visibly appealing from Alaskan Road and will have a pedestrian access. So, it's more than just a metal box storage facility.2:33:53 This really is an integrated multi-use development that will provide a variety of uses, new retail opportunities, and a modern uh storage facility and service for the for the uh community. Um and in terms of an environmental impacts and storm water impacts that were raised. Um again we did our environmental study, we have um environmental engineer uh conduct that study in response to specific comments from the2:34:21 community and we also have the project engineer here to speak to any storm water questions that you'all may have.2:34:26 Typically, when you have a development, that usually increases the um storm water treatment and quality um on the property just because it's not running off of the parking lot into the marsh land, it will allow for the storm water to be redirected into dedicated dry ponds on the property. So, we believe that the development will actually increase the uh decrease any or not have any material environmental impacts, but2:34:51 also increase the storm water uh treatment on the property as well. but happy to defer to the project engineer if there's any specific questions on that comment. So again, thank you for your time.2:35:01 Any questions, Josh?2:35:03 Um, thank you very much. Um, since I I think a lot of this and just reading through this staff report, um, is and the recommendation is it turns on the the use itself and the storage use. Um uh and and we heard a little bit from the the person who was marketing the property for [sighs] potentially other uses and we didn't we didn't finish hearing from him just because of time constraints. So um he began talking2:35:30 about access being a challenge and how that wasn't a signalized intersection right there. We've heard about the Navy um AUS and flight restrictions. Um I mean just anybody looking at um site layout can see that it's a tight site.2:35:48 Um and you know my my understanding that there there are also parking issues and challenges with other types of uses in that location. Um you know specifically if it were just a retail use. So, I'm I'm interested in hearing more if I could, mayor, from the person who is actually trying to market the property for those other uses. If that's what this is going to turn on, um that we don't want that use there, well,2:36:15 how realistic is another use there? Um would it be possible to hear from that person again?2:36:20 Yeah, I think Yeah, let's go ahead and hear from them. We need a clarification on this.2:36:27 We'll make it part of the rebuttal.2:36:34 [clears throat] [snorts] Thank you guys. Appreciate the time. Um, so let me uh start off where I left off.2:36:46 Um, so I told you guys about the uh property of the history or the history of the property. Um, and I started going into the challenges. So to piggyback off what you were saying there, um, the first is access obviously. Uh the absence of the signalized entrance at this particular property creates challenges for the certain types of commercial uses especially those that rely on the convenient ingress egress2:37:12 during peak business hours which you can see as an example the movie theater letting multiple showings out at one time. You're stuck in a parking lot for maybe 20 minutes trying to make a left-hand turn out of the non signalized entrance. Um the second challenge that we've really ran into was the development economics. Um even when the prospective tenant or developer would find this location attractive, once we2:37:40 started running the numbers, the cost of acquiring, improving, redeveloping the property, um it started to make less financial sense. Um ultimately that investment has to be justified by the revenue the property can generate. Um in our experience that combination of access limitations and the redevelopment o e economics has made it difficult to move um alter alternative projects forward. Um so that brings me to the2:38:11 current proposal that's under consideration. Um, what I find compelling about this redevelopment is that it takes a different approach to addressing those challenges of the access, the economics rather than relying on the single hightra commercial use to support the entire property.2:38:29 We're spreading that over. So, you have the paddle concept, you have the self- storage concept, you have the retail underneath the self- storage. So being able to spread that over the entire development, you're talking about potentially three different uses. Um it starts to finally make sense. Um as uh Tyler was saying, the self- storage component generally does have lower traffic demands um than many of the2:38:59 retail and restaurant uses while also helping support the overall economics of the redevelopment. Um that in turn creates opportunity to incorporate the 8,000 ft² of retail [gasps] um as well as a paddle uh component. And from a leasing perspective, I think that's a important distinction. Um so we're not simply talking about placing a conventional self- storage facility along Alaskan Road. We're talking about2:39:26 a coordinated redevelopment that incorporates street facing commercial retail space, recreational activity with the paddle facility, and then the architectural design intended to resemble traditional office or retail building. Um, the proposed retail frontage and patio areas would create opportunities for activity along the corridor, while the overall project would bring a property that has2:39:50 struggled for years back into productive use. Um and then I also wanted to address the suggestion that the property may need more time um to market. Um certainly understand that perspective.2:40:04 Um as a commercial real estate broker, I would welcome the opportunity to bring a successful restaurant or retail development to this location. Um and that's exactly initially what we spent years pursuing those opportunities. Um, but there's an important distinction between identifying a use that would be desirable for the property and ad identifying one that realistically could be developed. Um, so after 5 years of2:40:33 marketing, including extensive outreach to national the local operators, we've had a meaning opportunity to test the market. Um and while another opportunity could certainly emerge in the future, additional marketing time alone doesn't resolve the access limitations um and the underlying developed economics um that challenges property for years. So it in my opinion the proposal before council represents a2:41:02 practical solution to addressing those constraints while still creating opportunities for the retail services and recreation along Alaskan Road.2:41:13 Thanks. Thank you. I think you answered my question. You you first initially had 6,000 square feet. You bumped it to 8,000. That's correct. And was that in response to the community's desire for additional retail?2:41:24 That's correct. So, our ideal was That was all I needed. That was all I needed to know. Thank you.2:41:30 Okay. Any other questions worth?2:41:32 Yep. Can you um just u thanks for the clarification there, but for further clarification to me as a fellow broker, when you market 4.2 two acres with a movie theater there and you did I'm sure you did you all did a great job because the podel facility is here so congratulations and thank you but to me that's different now once closing happened then this site uh comes up for the market and it's a totally different2:42:00 scenario marking 4.2 two acres with a movie theater versus just plain parking lot land for a restaurant or limited retail or all the B2 uses that I'm going to ask the planning director here in a minute to explain.2:42:12 Isn't there there a distinction and clarification? So, in other words, this particular parcel has not been on the market for 5 years. Just this particular one.2:42:20 That's correct. Yeah. So, to clarify, you're correct. The 4.2 acres was originally proposed with the previous ownership.2:42:28 um new ownership got it under contract and that is when I started working on it which has been August September of 2025.2:42:40 Okay. Okay. Anybody else at this point?2:42:42 I would just like to ask.2:42:43 Okay.2:42:44 Um for community outreach, how many community meetings did you have and how many people showed up?2:42:53 I think uh Tyler could answer to that.2:42:56 Okay.2:42:58 pass the baton.2:43:00 No problem. Thank you. Um yeah, so we conducted two community meetings. Um and so the first community meeting was held on the property site. Um there I think we only had probably two or three people show up to that meeting. We sent out flyers to all the adjacent property owners um including the apartment complexes. the some of the feedback from that community meeting was that the2:43:28 information in the meeting information did not give properly or or it wasn't widely circulated and people didn't know about it. So, we held a second uh community meeting at the oceanfront library. We sent out all the um flyers to the adjacent property owners in the apartment complexes. I personally called all the um apartment complexes around there to ensure that they received the2:43:52 notices and that they were giving them out and making the tenants aware of them. Um personally I emailed everyone who sent in a letter of opposition um regarding the project and then the meeting was advertised on the city website. Um and at that second community meeting we still had I think three members of the public attend that community meeting.2:44:17 Okay. Anybody else?2:44:18 Sorry, I got one more since you came back. I got one for you, too. Um, so considering the fact that you've got that that the seller is the same in the Padell development, redevelopment of the movie theater and then and then this resubdivided parcel. Um, can you speak to cuz I I I'm assuming the timeline for the Pedell facility is moving forward and could potentially move forward um alongside2:44:49 um a redevelopment of this new parcel.2:44:51 Correct. So, so if if we were or if the there was a suggestion that that we you know that the seller somehow sit on the on the smaller piece and see what kind of fish might bite over the next year or so. Um I I would imagine that would impact construction somewhat on the Padell site and considering it's the same seller could [cough] potentially um you know uh affect you know things like2:45:20 pricing dynamics at the at this the new facility that they're building or feasibility of it. I'm just kind of wondering does it make sense from a land use and development perspective to handle these two sites together versus peace meal?2:45:36 Um so I trying to may try to rephrase the question. So in terms of the development timeline for the Pedell facility and then a subsequent development on the other subdivided parcel. So the Pedell facility I believe is proceeding with their internal demolition at this point. And again we have the property owner here as well um to maybe speak to the PEL side.2:45:58 Um in terms of the two projects um they are independent projects and in terms of um them relying on each other in terms of development um uh either obligations or things of that nature.2:46:14 They're they're independent of of each other. So I don't think the one would really necessarily impact the other.2:46:20 Obviously they'll be neighbors and adjacent and the same property. So, um but in terms of um specific de development considerations for the Pedell facility, um that's not something that I've heard has been um tied to this particular development or the any other development on the other side of the property.2:46:41 Okay. Anybody else at this point?2:46:44 Okay. Thank you.2:46:45 Thank you.2:46:46 Okay. Uh let's have a motion.2:46:48 Can I Yeah.2:46:49 make the motion after I give my reasons?2:46:52 Yes.2:46:52 Okay. Thank Thank you, mayor. First of all, thank everybody, the developer, especially for your interest in this corridor. This is um this piece of property I've watched for several years, the movie theater. I can name about 10 great movies I saw there. I'm so sorry to see that leave, but that's life and that's changed. Um so, I'm so happy for the Podel facility. So, again, thanks to2:47:14 everyone for your emails uh coming down tonight to speak, but I'm so excited about the Podel facility. I did uh go to their Richmond operation and it is a really really cool uh reuse repurpose for the movie theater and I think it's under construction now. But you've already heard um where I stand and and I'm going to move here in a minute to um ask for denial of the application. Um2:47:37 and there are four reasons. I'll I'll mention all four and then go through each one. Uh I'll ask the planning director in a minute. The the city planning staff uh has recommended uh denial for the reasons we heard earlier.2:47:49 Um also uh the city planning commission in this room heard this application that they voted 7 to3 uh to deny the application as you heard also earlier the city our city has spent I have not uh checked this but it's I will say millions but I heard tonight $40 million but it's a lot of millions of dollars to enhance this Alaskan gateway to the oceanfront 31st street and is a great2:48:14 place right now for a lot of B2 retail right in this area. Uh fourth and and almost as important as anything, the public and the public includes local business owners that have contacted me that have contacted uh members of council uh to oppose this application for a lot of the reasons which you've heard tonight what I'm trying to explain. So the public uh I thought it's signed over a thousand u signatures on a2:48:40 petition. I heard earlier tonight 2,000 but that's whether it's a thousand or two it's a lot. A lot of these folks do live in this area. Um, we got a lot of emails from the public and 16 out of the 18 letters received by the planning comm uh staff are in opposition. So, those four reasons are uh the basis for my uh move for uh denial. And if I could ask2:49:04 the planning director to state um why the planning staff recommended denial and also um this property is zone B2. It is impacted. Yes, no question about the air rights. It is AP uh APZ2 which is less restrict restrictive than APZ1, but Director Walsh, can you explain why the staff recommended denial?2:49:28 Yes, sir. Thank you. So, as you know, our SGAAs are long range redevelopment plans for certain areas of the city. The Raceap is just that for the resort. This is a very important corridor gateway going into our oceanfront, our resort area. So a primary use like self storage, in this case 126,000 square ft, and then only 8,000 square ft of retail, we would consider not a compatible use2:49:58 with our long range planning. We want it to be uh pedestrian oriented. We provided, I believe it was October 30, excuse me, 23rd, a city council staff report to the city council showing the number of uh uses that could go on this site. Just an example of a few would be bakeries, eating and drinking establishments, gift shops, grocery, etc. There's a a long list and that's more of what we would consider an2:50:32 appropriate use to activate the street in this area.2:50:38 So if you stood at this site and you looked across the street and down the street, you would see any number of B2 really cool uses, retail uses. That is that correct?2:50:48 If there are similar uses, yes.2:50:50 Right. So for those reasons, um council um move forward denial of the application. Is there a second?2:50:57 A second.2:51:00 Okay. Open for discussion.2:51:03 All right. I'll get it going. Um, I'm concerned about a denial for this property.2:51:09 Uh, you know, once again, this is a very complicated property. There's not a lot of stuff they can do on it. And I really haven't heard anything about a viable option tonight. And the last thing I think this city needs is another blank area just sitting in perpetuity with nothing going on.2:51:34 Uh, you know, I I was mentored by a wonderful man when I first got on council, Lewis Jones, and he talked about this thing called the highest and best use. And he also advised me against competition as being a reason for denial.2:51:52 And you know once again you know if there was a better plan it should have been out here but this is the one that we got to deal with right now. And I had a call that really, you know, kind of, you know, upset me a bit today when I was talking about, you know, somebody was asked to call me uh to talk against this thing.2:52:15 And I told him of the merit. And you know, once again, you know, this is kind of a gateway, but you know, the real gateway is 264.2:52:23 And it's the thing to me that, you know, once you reach the pinnacle, you know, that's it. But once again, right across the street from this, you have Eurasia and you have a bunch of other retail.2:52:34 And the gentleman that I spoke to today, uh, he said, "Well, I want to speak against it, you know, for all the reasons we had here today." And then I mentioned, well, it's going to not look like a storage facility. It's going to blend into the thing. And, you know, right on uh Indian River Road, uh, Mike Siphon put a beautiful storage place that you don't even know it's a storage2:52:56 place. Okay. [gasps] But then when I mentioned there was 8,000 uh you know square ft of retail there, he said, "Oh, I didn't realize that." And I can see kind of the argument if you know if it was just a storage facility per se, but there was an innovation here about putting retail in there. And from what I understand, a pickle ball uh place is going to be adjacent to there and2:53:22 everything. And I feel how Yeah. I feel how it meets fails to meet the aesthetics of what we're trying to do because people are going to be zipping by and just going forward and you know and once again you really know that you hit the u the beach zone when you see that marvelous uh artwork there in the pinnacle building that's when people start notice when you see the tra2:53:50 transition there uh but once again I am reluctant to have vacant property. You know, there are so many restrictions on this. What's going to be acceptable?2:54:02 People didn't want a church there. Uh, you know, what's going to be acceptable to people? And I think, you know, this is an opportunity, you know, in a time of economic time, you know, it's a Marine Corps thing and today's Marine Corps's birthday, improvise, adapt, and overcome.2:54:19 and we're going to have a a briefing next week on the billions of dollars that we're going to be needing to confront our storm water obligations.2:54:29 And you know, once again, I think this is a practical use and I invite any other conversation, but [sighs] you know, it's uh um you know, this is a tough one. I'll admit it. You know, there's a lot of emotion in this one, but ultimately I feel the right thing to do is to uh you know, approve this. So, I will be uh voting to deny the denial. Anybody else?2:54:54 Jennifer.2:54:56 Thank you, mayor. Um I'll support the council member in the denial. And I'll say the it is complicated when we have land use restrictions and all of that.2:55:05 And the the issue I have is the I think it's okay to wait on some properties. So if there's a sense of um something where the community can come together at least with not as much opposition if possible um recognizing that not everyone will be satisfied with every option but I think um vacant land that there's no rush to develop it um sometimes this it's fine for the space to breathe for a bit until2:55:34 there's something that um more people can agree on. So, um I just wanted to make [clears throat] a comment about that that um I think some vacant space is fine so long as there's no urgency or harm in it in waiting for something better. Thank you.2:55:47 Okay. Thank you.2:55:49 Um Josh and Amelia. Um yeah, and this this was a difficult one because you know that the Alaskan corridor is is is a gateway um and and we do have aesthetic standards that um and and use attributes that that we want to make sure that that we have along that corridor and other major corridors.2:56:14 um you know but but I I can't get around the fact where you know the our our planning documents are are there for good reason. They are they are aspirational and um I think sometimes the aspirational meets economic realities and that's what our job is for. Um and um as much as we might might want a brewery or some amazing restaurant in that location, um you know, we just we2:56:44 just heard from the people who own the property and who've marketed it and who are trying to make economic use of the property that those uses aren't economically feasible. Um especially given the site constraints. Um, and I [snorts] do think the community came together in some respects because, you know, after the movie theater went away, they came together and they said they didn't want a church there. So, um, they2:57:05 put in a pretty awesome entertainment use that'll be coming, um, you know, with Pedell facility. Um, but they had a residue parcel that they really couldn't do anything with because it was a challenging site. So um so that kind of leaves me I mean if the use is the real issue I mean what specific land use incompat incompatibility remains that can't be cured by conditions and I think2:57:29 I think they've tried their best I mean they've added not just the 6,000 square foot of retail they bumped it to 8,000 who said there who says there can't be a great restaurant or some other complimentary retail use to to draw to to draw off of the the the Padell uh facility. Um you know, they've made the architectural standards look like an office building as opposed to a storage2:57:54 facility. I don't know that I really it bothers me that that much that there's stuff inside the building instead of people. Um, and uh, it certainly is nice that there won't be as much traffic and and I think you know just as I'm sitting here thinking about it, it's just um, you know, is is this project isn't it is is it because this project isn't what we ne necessarily want to see here. You2:58:18 know, it's not our first choice. I mean, that might be the case, but it's also it's also not demonstrabably inappropriate for that area. So, for that reason, um, I'll be also voting no to the denial.2:58:30 Hey Amelia.2:58:31 Yes, I ended up visiting the area to really see because sometimes what you see on the screen like up there doesn't really give it its value. And I even ask about the wetlands which are behind the building once it's put up as well as I like the idea of the storage that will go behind. People will enter from behind. So actually if you're looking at the building just for the front passing2:58:59 by it does not look like a sourish and it's important that we continue to get tax revenue for the flooding and so forth that will help our community.2:59:13 So, I'd also ask, what about recreation?2:59:16 And then we saw where Patel, like you mentioned, is going to have the recreation area and they even going to put a walking a walking path across the front. So, the building is not sitting right against the front.2:59:30 Those were important, you know, amenities to see that they have that.2:59:35 And uh moved it up to what 8 foot eight for the retail. And even you all mentioned today about talking about having not only the retail stores there but other opportunities that can happen having along that stretch. So you have the recreation, you have the walkability of that and like you mentioned mayor is further down but the gateway not right excuse my throat not right at the beginning.3:00:08 So you know those are my comments listening to the work they have done. I ask about putting up um what other thing will fit in well with that area and you have been through the process of looking at what will work and we're down to not having it as an empty space. It's becomes an eyesore.3:00:32 Those are just my comments.3:00:33 Thank you Michael and then Stacy.3:00:36 Thank you mayor. U I'm going to support council member Ramik and his recommendation for a denial this evening. Um and I just want to say a few words about that. I have a lot I have I can sympathize with the applicant and the property owners um in dealing with a property that is encumbered by so many restrictions. But those restrictions were known to all of you when you began this process. And I think what the3:01:01 conversations about the church revealed and the movie theater is that this is a beloved um part of our community. No matter where you live in Virginia Beach, we have fond memories of um of this uh part of our city. And and I do too. I I saw some good movies there and I saw some bad movies there too. And and I have a lot of fun uh memories with my3:01:23 friends growing up there and so does so many other people from our community. So there's a broad investment in what happens here and and I think that's a good thing. Um I can appreciate the incumbrances. I can appreciate the position you're in. Um but I don't think enough community engagement has occurred here um in a way that is really responsive to the concerns that have been raised and in particular with the3:01:47 um elevated community interest in this particular property and the historic role that has played in our lives for so many decades. And um it's just not ready. And that's what I said. That's what I said when when we when I talked to you all. Um and that's what I've heard from the community too. It's not ready. And so for that reason and at this time at this juncture um I'm going3:02:12 to support the council member in his recommend recommendation over denial with the hope that we can get to a place where there's something there the community can continue. I don't know what the new iteration of the Surf and Sam movie theater is, but it would be great to envision the next um the next chapter of that property in an innovative new way, but it's not storage. Okay, Stacy,3:02:39 if I can ask the planning director, if it were not for the storage component of this project, if but it was simply a 8,000 square foot retail um facility.3:02:54 What would have been the staff's uh view on that?3:03:01 So staff and and this is I'm just reading directly from our staff report, but based on a preliminary analysis, staff believes that the site reasonably could support a 10,000 square ft eating and drinking establishment or 20,000 square ft of retail or personal service uses or com combination thereof. So in that case, it would be support from the staff.3:03:26 Okay. Anybody else at this point?3:03:29 Okay, we'll open the vote. An affirmative I is a vote for denial.3:03:34 Correct. Okay.3:03:36 Yes. The motion is to deny.3:03:39 The vote is open.3:03:44 So, close it so we can see by a vote of 6 to 5. The denial. This application has been denied.3:03:55 Okay.3:03:57 that will of the council have passed.3:03:59 Thank you.3:04:06 Okay. Any uh appointments?3:04:15 What do appointments?3:04:16 Appointments.3:04:18 Yes, Mr. Mayor. um active transportation advisory committee to appoint um [clears throat] Sean Tash and Logan Kieran and for the Green Ribbon uh committee to appoint Evan Ross Brockwell. Move for approval.3:04:35 Second.3:04:37 Okay.3:04:39 One second.3:04:39 All right. Let's open the vote.3:04:41 Just one second, please.3:04:47 The vote is open.3:04:53 Uh, Council Member Hutcherson, Jackson Green, and Cummings, may I have your vote, please?3:05:01 Council member Cummings.3:05:03 Stacy, Hutcherson, and Jackson Green. Okay. And Jackson Green, may I have your vote?3:05:12 Is it not working for you all? This is for appointments.3:05:17 Thank you.3:05:20 By vote of 11 to zero, you have appointed those read by Vice Mayor Wilson.3:05:26 Okay. All right. Any unfinished business? New business. Okay. Let's adjourn into open mic.
Spotted a mistake? and we’ll check it against the source.